Sleeping Pads

Nemo Eclipse vs Exped Ultra 6.5R: Two Ultralight Sleeping Pads Compared

A head-to-head look at two sub-560 g all-season sleeping pads, covering comfort, warmth, valve design, durability, and the one weakness they share.

Two ultralight rectangular sleeping pads laid side by side on a concrete floor

Introduction

The Nemo Eclipse and the Exped Ultra 6.5R occupy a very similar place in the ultralight sleeping pad market. Both are rectangular all-season pads with R-values above 6, both weigh a little under 560 g in the regular wide rectangular size, and both sit close to the $200 mark. The Eclipse is listed at $190 and 558 g, while the Ultra 6.5R comes in at $200 and 551 g.

On paper they look almost interchangeable. In practice they differ in comfort, warmth, valve design, and the way they behave on colder nights. There is also one shared weakness worth knowing about before you spend the money.

How These Two Sleeping Pads Compare

Five things shape the experience of any sleeping pad: ease of use, noise, comfort, warmth, and durability. Price and weight sit around all five, and here they are nearly identical, so the differences that matter come from design choices rather than from the spec sheet.

Both pads are quiet in use. Their shells and insulation constructions avoid the crinkling and squeaking that cheaper pads produce, both on rocky ground and on a tent floor. That is a meaningful quality-of-life detail on a long trip, and neither pad gives you a reason to complain.

Interior of a lightweight backpacking tent at dusk with a sleeping pad laid flat on the floor

Comfort comes down to two things: pressure relief and stability. Warmth comes down to the R-value and how the insulation is built. Durability comes down to shell fabric and weld construction. The two pads take different routes to each of those goals, which is what makes the comparison interesting.

Nemo Eclipse: Comfort First

The Eclipse is four inches thick, half an inch more than the Ultra 6.5R, and that extra depth makes it harder to bottom out, especially when you deliberately let some air out for a softer feel.

Its baffling is vertical but subtly dimpled along each baffle line. Each dimple has a little give and behaves a bit like a spring, which helps spread pressure. The pad also uses larger outer tubes than the Exped, and those tubes do a noticeably better job of keeping you centred, to the point where the pad feels cradling rather than flat. The Eclipse has no stretchy top material, so its pressure relief comes from the dimpled structure rather than from fabric stretch.

Warmth is rated at R-value 6.2 using two suspended layers of reflective film, the same approach used in the Tensor All Season line. Setup uses a single one-way valve on top of the pad with two flaps: one for inflation, one to dump air. The shell is 30 denier nylon, with a ripstop weave on top for grip and a plain weave underneath for puncture resistance. In the regular wide rectangular size it weighs 558 g and costs $190.

Exped Ultra 6.5R: Warmer, and Lighter in Mummy Form

The Ultra 6.5R carries the higher R-value at 6.9. Its insulation is unusual: a layer of synthetic material is welded to the top of each baffle, and a reflective film is glued onto that synthetic layer, so the insulation floats close to your body rather than filling the whole pad. Vertical baffles keep the surface stable from the centre to the edges, the top material has a slight stretch that adds pressure relief, and the outer tubes are raised and thicker to help keep you centred, though that effect is less pronounced than on the Eclipse.

The shell is 20 denier polyester with continuous vertical welds running through each baffle, the same construction used on earlier Exped Ultra pads. Inflation and deflation use two separate valves, which changes the ownership experience considerably.

Deflated ultralight sleeping pad rolled up beside a loaded hiking backpack on a tent floor

The regular wide rectangular version weighs 551 g and costs $200. There is also a mummy version that weighs 425 g, more than 100 g lighter, which makes it the more interesting option for trips where every gram counts.

Ease of Use and Valve Design

This is where the two pads separate most clearly. The Exped uses a separate valve for inflation and another for deflation. In a small tent that means flipping the pad over once it is inflated, which is awkward, and it makes firmness adjustments during the night harder than they should be. If the temperature drops and you want to bleed off a little air or top the pad up, the Exped does not make that easy.

The Eclipse puts a single one-way valve on top of the pad. Open one flap to inflate, open the second to dump air, and adjust firmness at any point without moving off the pad. Pressing the valve releases a little air, and adding air while lying on it is just as simple. It is a well-resolved system, and it is the single biggest day-to-day advantage in this comparison.

Both pads ship with inflation bags that work well, and both deflate and roll up without fuss.

Warmth: Both Pads Sleep Colder Than Their Ratings Suggest

Both pads are all-season designs rather than winter pads, and neither brand markets them for deep winter use. Even so, the gap between their rated warmth and their real-world warmth is worth flagging. The Eclipse, rated at R-value 6.2, starts to feel cold at around -3 to -4 °C, which is lower than the rating implies. The Ultra 6.5R, rated at 6.9, holds on to roughly -5 to -6 °C before cold spots appear.

Frost forming on the inner wall of a cold-weather tent at dawn above a sleeping pad and quilt

That is a shared limitation rather than a flaw in one pad, and it is consistent with how thin, lightweight insulation behaves in practice. Both still sleep warm for their weight, and both remain comfortable well below freezing in spring, summer, and autumn conditions. Treat the R-values as guidance for three-season use, and plan a warmer system if you expect sustained sub-zero nights.

Durability and Warranty Coverage

The Ultra 6.5R uses the same 20 denier polyester construction as earlier Exped Ultra pads, which have held up well over time, and its continuous vertical welds run the length of each baffle. Earlier Exped baffle welds had a reputation for blowing out, but that appears to have been addressed in the current Ultra line.

The Eclipse uses 30 denier nylon with a different weave top and bottom, and its welds are individual points at each dimple. Nemo previously had pinhole leaks develop at weld points, an issue that has since been resolved. Both pads come with strong warranties, so a manufacturing defect is unlikely to leave you out of pocket.

Which Sleeping Pad Should You Buy?

The choice comes down to a small trade-off. The Exped is slightly warmer and the Nemo is slightly more comfortable. If you regularly camp below freezing, the Ultra 6.5R is the more sensible pick. If sub-zero nights are rare and you want the pad you look forward to lying on, the Eclipse is the better answer.

Overhead flat-lay of an ultralight backpacking sleep system arranged on a concrete surface

Weight can tip the decision too. The two rectangular pads are within a few grams of each other, but the mummy version of the Ultra 6.5R at 425 g is over 100 g lighter, which is a significant saving for a pad this warm and this comfortable. For a long thru-hike or any trip where pack weight is the priority, that version is hard to argue with. For a balanced three-season kit, the Eclipse is the pad most people will be happier with.

Conclusion

The Nemo Eclipse and the Exped Ultra 6.5R are both excellent all-season sleeping pads, and neither is a mistake. Choose the Exped for maximum warmth and the lighter mummy option, and choose the Nemo for the most comfortable night and the most user-friendly valve in the category. Whichever you pick, plan for the reality that both pads sleep a little colder than their R-values suggest.

Further reading

Related Reviews

Three inflatable backpacking sleeping pads unrolled on a concrete floor

Sleeping Pads

Best Backpacking Sleeping Pads 2026: Nine Pads Rated on Price, Comfort, Warmth, and Weight

Nine backpacking sleeping pads compared on price, comfort, warmth, and weight, from a $65 summer pad to a year-round option rated at R-7.3.

9/26/2026
Three inflatable backpacking sleeping pads side by side on a concrete floor

Sleeping Pads

Best Backpacking Sleeping Pads: Comfort, Warmth, and Weight Compared

A practical comparison of the Nemo Quasar 3D, Therm-a-Rest NeoAir XTherm Max, and Big Agnes Rapide SL for backpackers choosing between comfort, warmth, and packed weight.

9/26/2026
Three rolled backpacking sleeping pads on a matte concrete surface, one partly unrolled

Sleeping Pads

Best Backpacking Sleeping Pads: Ultralight, Winter, Comfort and Budget Picks

A practical roundup of the sleeping pads that stand out for ultralight weight, winter warmth, pressure relief and value, plus three popular pads that fell short.

9/26/2026