Backpacking Gear
Five Backpacking Gear Swaps Worth Making
Five categories of backpacking gear where lighter, more versatile alternatives took over from long-serving favourites, plus what to weigh before you make the same swaps.
Introduction
Gear coverage tends to focus on what is new. The more useful question, over several seasons of hiking, is what quietly leaves the pack. A handful of long-serving items have now been set aside, not because they failed outright, but because something lighter, more efficient or simply more comfortable took their place.
The five swaps below cover headlamps, rain jackets, sit pads, a camera-friendly fanny pack and long-sleeve button-up shirts. Each item started as a favourite. Each has now been replaced.

None of this means the outgoing gear was a mistake. A jacket that wets out after years of use has still done its job, and a shirt that no longer suits your style of hiking has still earned its miles. The point is to show what changed and why, so you can decide whether the same trade-offs apply to your own kit.
How These Swaps Were Chosen
Three criteria run through every swap on this list: weight, function and comfort. A replacement has to save grams, add a capability the outgoing item did not have, or make long days on the trail noticeably easier. Ideally it does more than one of those things.
Battery life and light output matter more than a few grams for anyone hiking after dark or riding a bike at speed. Multi-use foam matters more than a single-purpose seat pad. Breathability and coverage matter more than a collar and buttons.
Price is deliberately not a criterion here. Every swap on this list is about what works better on the trail rather than about spending less, and the outgoing items were not bad purchases at the time.
UCO Air 150 Headlamp: The Long-Serving Original
The UCO Air 150 is a 150-lumen USB-rechargeable headlamp with a red light and a dial for adjusting output. With a shock cord modification, it drops to roughly one ounce. It has been in service since 2017 across thru-hikes, backpacking trips and bikepacking trips, and it has performed well throughout.
What changed is the type of use. Riding and night hiking demand more light and longer runtime than 150 lumens comfortably delivers.
Nitecore NU25 Headlamp: Brighter and Longer Running
The Nitecore NU25 keeps the same USB-rechargeable approach and, with a shock cord modification, comes in at about 1.1 ounces. It offers multiple modes, including more than one red light setting, along with adjustable output. At 360 lumens it is substantially brighter than the UCO Air 150, and its battery life is considerably longer.
Why Brightness and Battery Life Matter After Dark
Headlamp choice is usually framed as a weight question, and the lightest option tends to win. That framing holds up until you start moving faster than walking pace. On a bike, or on a trail you are trying to cover before the temperature drops, a dim beam forces you to slow down and pick your way through terrain you would otherwise read at a glance.

Runtime matters for the same reason. A headlamp that needs recharging mid-trip adds a dependency, especially across longer stretches between resupply points. A brighter lamp with a longer runtime covers more of the situations a hiker actually runs into, which is why the swap makes sense even when the outgoing light has been reliable for years.
Zpacks Vertice Rain Jacket: When a Shell Wets Out
The Zpacks Vertice earned its place over multiple seasons. The first one, picked up in 2017, covered a large number of miles before it wore out and had to be replaced. The feature set is strong: pit zips, a fully adjustable hood, a longer cut and bungee adjustment.
The second Vertice did not hold up the same way. It wetted out quickly and stopped keeping rain out well before the first one had reached that point.
Enlightened Equipment Visp Rain Jacket: Drier in Sustained Rain
The Enlightened Equipment Visp uses a very similar material to the Vertice, and it has kept rain out far more effectively. It resists wetting out for longer and breathes a little better. It also keeps the features that matter, including pit zips and a fully adjustable hood.
The trade-offs are minor. The cut is shorter than the Vertice, and it does not have the same bungee adjustment. For staying dry in sustained rain, that is an acceptable compromise.
Therm-a-Rest Z Seat: The Classic Sit Pad
The Therm-a-Rest Z Seat is a closed-cell foam seat pad that does two jobs well. It keeps you dry when you sit on wet ground or a damp log at camp, and it can be folded to act as a windscreen for a stove. It has moved in and out of the kit for years, and it has never been a weight problem.
Gossamer Gear Thinlight Foam Pad: More Functions at a Similar Weight
The Gossamer Gear Thinlight foam pad is a torso-length foam pad that folds down to serve as a seat pad and unfolds into a siesta mat for a midday nap. It doubles as a stretching surface at the end of the day, and it can be laid under an inflatable sleeping pad for extra protection and a little more warmth on cold nights.
At torso length it weighs about 1.8 ounces, close to the sit pad it replaces. For a small weight difference, it covers several more situations.
Waymark Zip Fanny Pack: Outgrown by a Camera Change
The Waymark Zip fanny pack was picked up to solve a specific problem: carrying a compact mirrorless camera, a tripod and a microphone on the trail. At the time it was exactly the right size for that setup, filling the gap between a shoulder pouch that was too small and a strap clip designed for a larger camera.
Once the camera setup changed, the bag lost its purpose. The larger camera works with a shoulder strap clip, the smaller one fits a shoulder pouch, and a tripod and microphone fit in a side pocket.
Why Button-Up Hiking Shirts Fell Out of Favour
Button-up hiking shirts have a long track record. A long-sleeve button-up offers coverage, ventilation and a collar that keeps sun off the neck, and it has been a standard recommendation for desert and high-altitude hiking for years.

The case for a sun hoodie comes down to options. Long sleeves can be worn down or rolled up, thumb holes keep the fabric over the backs of the hands, and a hood covers the neck and ears without a separate hat or buff. On a windy ridge, that hood also blocks cold air from the side of the face, which is harder to achieve with a collar alone.
Columbia Silver Ridge Hiking Shirt: The Durable Standard
The Columbia Silver Ridge long-sleeve shirt is the kind of button-up that earns years of use: light fabric, useful ventilation and enough coverage for long days in the sun. It has been a dependable trail shirt for a long time, and it remains a sensible choice for anyone who prefers a collar and buttons.
Arc’teryx Skyline Shirt: The Lighter Button-Up
The Arc’teryx Skyline shirt is the other long-sleeve button-up in the rotation, a lighter and more technical take on the same idea. It handles heat and long days under a pack comfortably.
Both shirts do what a button-up should. The reason they are being set aside is not performance, it is that a single hooded garment now covers more ground.
Outdoor Research Echo Sun Hoodie: The New Default
The Outdoor Research Echo Sun Hoodie was first carried as an extra layer for hikes with long exposed sections: desert terrain, high ridgelines, anywhere the sun and wind are constant. It has thumb holes, a hood that covers the neck and ears, and long sleeves that can be pushed up when the temperature climbs.
It proved so useful that it became the primary hiking top, worn all day and used for wind protection as much as for sun protection.
Buying Advice
If you are weighing a similar set of swaps, start with how you actually use each item. A headlamp that only lights up camp does not need 360 lumens. A rain jacket that only sees light showers does not need to survive days of sustained rain. A button-up shirt is still a good choice if you prefer a collar and buttons to a hood and thumb holes.

Look for replacements that add a function rather than only subtracting weight. A foam pad that doubles as a nap mat, a shell that resists wetting out, a headlamp that runs longer between charges: those are the changes you notice on the trail, not on a spreadsheet. The best swap is the one that matches the trips you actually take.
Conclusion
Five categories, five replacements, and one common thread: each new item does more than the one it replaced. The Nitecore NU25 covers faster night travel, the Enlightened Equipment Visp stays drier in sustained rain, the Gossamer Gear Thinlight foam pad handles seating, napping and insulation, and the Outdoor Research Echo Sun Hoodie replaces a whole category of trail shirts. The Waymark fanny pack is the exception, retired because the camera kit it was built around no longer exists.
The outgoing gear was not wasted money. It was used hard, it worked for a long time, and it taught you what to look for next. That is usually how a kit gets better.









