Multi-Tools
Victorinox SwissTool MX Clip vs Leatherman Free P4: Two Premium Multi-Tools Compared
The SwissTool MX Clip brings a one-handed blade to Victorinox's spirit design, but stiff tool deployment and a premium price leave the Leatherman Free P4 as a serious rival.
Introduction
Victorinox entering the dedicated multi-tool market for the US audience felt like a long time coming, and the SwissTool MX Clip is the company’s take on a pocket-carry multi-tool with a built-in clip. It arrived in 2021, and it sits at roughly the $150 to $160 mark depending on where you buy it. Is it worth that money, and how does it stack up against the Leatherman Free P4? After spending real time with it, the honest answer is more nuanced than the marketing suggests.
What Sets the SwissTool MX Clip Apart
The headline feature is the one-handed blade. It is identical in length to the original SwissTool blade, so nothing has been sacrificed for size, and it opens with a thumb flick while your fingers never cross the cutting path when closing it. For anyone familiar with the older Victorinox spirit design, that single change is a genuine upgrade.

The pocket clip itself is a nice touch, though it is not really the main event. A small screw holds it in place, and the clip can be unscrewed and repositioned to the opposite side of the tool, mounting where the corkscrew section sits, so it can be set up for tip-up carry in either pocket. The screw is small, and it matters to know that a standard M2.5 screw fits it properly, which makes a replacement easy if it ever snaps. Aftermarket and alternative clips can also be attached to a Victorinox tool you already own, and those options cost less than the clip-equipped version of this tool.
Tool Set and Everyday Performance
The tool loadout follows the classic spirit layout. The can opener is the same excellent design found on nearly every Victorinox, arguably the best in the business. The flathead and two-dimensional Phillips are reliable, and the dedicated three-dimensional Phillips is genuinely impressive: long, stout, and capable of reaching deeply recessed fasteners.

The large flathead doubles as a serious prying tool, thick and robust enough to handle big fasteners or light prying work. The file deploys easily thanks to textured grip, and the reamer is very sharp and effortless to access.
Where Deployment Falls Short
The core problem that carried over from the original spirit is tool retention. Roughly four or five of the ten implements are genuinely difficult to open with a fingernail. The three-dimensional Phillips, the scissors, and the saw are the worst offenders: the scissors and saw are so tightly held that the practical method is to hook a fingertip inside and pinch them out, and if your fingers are larger, that may not even be possible.
This matters most when conditions are less than ideal. Wet hands, rain, or soft nails make stubborn deployment frustrating, and on a tool sold at this price the friction is hard to overlook. Modifying the tension would resolve it, but that means giving up warranty coverage, a trade-off each buyer has to weigh.
Pliers and Build Quality
The pliers are where the spirit lineage shines. Out of the box they are smooth, comfortable, and free of any pinch points thanks to well-shaped handle curvature, arguably more comfortable for extended use than the pliers on the Leatherman Wave. The tip is blunter than competing pliers, which makes them slightly less precise in tight spaces but better suited to twisting. There are no replaceable wire cutters, and cutting performance is the weakest capability here; it is fine for occasional EDC tasks but not something to rely on as a dedicated cutter.

Build quality overall is impeccable. Victorinox fit and finish is as good as it gets in this category, and this tool should last a lifetime of use.
The Leatherman Free P4 Alternative
At essentially the same price, roughly $150, the Leatherman Free P4 is the obvious counterargument. The tool sets are quite similar, but the Free P4 is completely one-hand operable across its implements, so deployment problems simply do not exist, and it also has better scissors and replaceable wire cutters. For a buyer who wants one tool that covers everything without modifications or workarounds, the Free P4 arguably does more out of the box.
Buying Advice
The SwissTool MX Clip is not a starter multi-tool; it is too expensive for that role. The clip version and the clip-less version sell for the same price, which is worth noting: buying the clip-less version and adding an inexpensive aftermarket clip is a sensible way to save money without losing anything functionally.
If quick access to tools matters most to you, the Free P4 handles deployment better. If you prize fit and finish above all and only need fast access to the blade, which is indeed the easiest tool to open here, the SwissTool MX Clip can still make sense. The ideal fix for the MX Clip would be a simple tension adjustment, which would resolve its one significant flaw.

Conclusion
The Victorinox SwissTool MX Clip is a beautifully made multi-tool with a genuinely useful one-handed blade and some of the best pliers and screwdrivers in the category. Its downfall is tool retention: several implements remain stubbornly difficult to open, the same problem present in the original spirit design, and at a $150 to $160 price point that is a hard flaw to forgive when the Leatherman Free P4 offers similar tooling with far easier access. Choose based on which weakness you can live with.

