Running Shoes
Salomon S/Lab Phantasm 3 Review: A Cushioned Carbon Racer Held Back by a Fussy Upper
A very good, highly cushioned carbon plate racing shoe with an excellent PEBA midsole, but the aero gaiter upper is complicated and fiddly.
Introduction
The Salomon S/Lab Phantasm 3 is Salomon’s top carbon plate road racing shoe, and it’s a fairly big update on the Phantasm 2. The headline change is an all-new upper, but the more meaningful story is the ride: this is a shoe at the higher-cushion end of the super shoe market that still turns over quickly. Pricing sits at £260 in the UK and $280 in the US, which places it among the priciest carbon racers available.
In a UK 9 / US 10, it weighs 185 g or 6.5 oz, a fair bit lighter than the previous model. Stack height is 39 mm at the heel and 33 mm at the forefoot for a 6 mm drop. Those are competitive numbers on paper, and in practice the shoe delivers a ride that is smooth, bouncy, and more comfortable than most carbon racers currently on the market.
Who This Shoe Is For
The Phantasm 3 is aimed at runners chasing their fastest road races, particularly half marathons and marathons. It rewards fast turnover and dialed-in form at top-end efforts, and during testing it handled everything from all-out 400 m reps on the track to long marathon-pace sessions with genuine comfort and protection.
It is not the most accessible carbon shoe, though. Runners who land further back on their heels, prefer a roomy fit, or want a shoe that forgives sloppy form at slower paces may find other racers more accommodating. Most runners should stick to their normal running shoe size, though the fit is close across the shoe and wide-footed testers might try half a size up.

Main Strengths
The midsole is the star here. Salomon uses a big wedge of Optivibe Plus PEBA foam running the full length of the shoe, and it feels more cushioned than most super shoes. It’s soft without being overly compressive, energetic without being aggressively bouncy, and it sinks in and bounces back rapidly. The energy blade carbon plate is scooped and sits quite low under the forefoot, so the ride never feels harsh.
Over the test runs, which included a solo half marathon on London streets and a 20-mile race run entirely at marathon pace or faster, the ride was smooth, efficient, punchy, and controlled. Fast through the transition, snappy in the toe-off, and light on the foot. Legs also felt good the day after hard efforts, thanks to that bouncy, protective feel. Once on the foot, the upper is genuinely one of the most comfortable carbon shoe uppers around, with a pleasant sock-like hold.

The shoe also coped better than expected at slower paces: at around 8-minute miles it didn’t hang the tester out to dry, which is reassuring for warming up and cooling down. It just clearly performs best when you’re running with serious intent.

Things to Consider Before Buying
The upper is the big complication. It’s built with aerodynamics in mind, developed with Swiss Side, with a fabric section that folds over the laces and a gaiter that rises over the ankle. Salomon’s research suggests it can knock up to 18 seconds off an elite-level 2:05 marathon, but for most runners the benefit is negligible, especially since regular running kit negates it anyway.
More practically, the gaiter design makes the shoe a faff to put on. You have to pull a stretchy section up your foot to reach the firmer collar, the laces are hidden underneath, there’s no heel pull tab, and wide-footed wearers will find themselves wrestling with material before getting seated. The first attempt was frustrating enough to nearly give up entirely.

Durability also raises a question: after roughly 50 km of testing, the heels already show noticeable cosmetic scuffing, with a minimal outsole limited to coverage on the forefoot and heel and a big cutout down the middle to save weight. The ride is excellent, but the getting-on process and the price make it a risky buy compared to alternatives like the Asics Metaspeed Edge Tokyo or Puma Fast-R 3, which are recommended ahead of it for chasing marathon-fast times.
Buying Advice
If you can try before buying, the Phantasm 3 is worth a run, especially if you value cushioned comfort in a carbon racer. Stick to your normal size, ignore the aerodynamic claims, and judge it on the ride, which is genuinely competitive at any level. It sits in the top half of carbon plate racing shoes but doesn’t quite stand out on performance or price enough to be a must-buy. Runners seeking a firmer, more aggressive, rocketed transition may prefer the Hoka Cielo X 1 3.0, the Asics Metaspeed Sky Tokyo, or the Puma Fast-R 3 instead.
Conclusion
The Salomon S/Lab Phantasm 3 is an excellent racing shoe that will likely be somewhat overlooked, partly because it doesn’t come from a traditional road running giant and partly because its aero gaiter design draws attention away from what actually matters. The midsole setup delivers fun, comfort, bounce, and speed in a lightweight package, and it will do a very good job, particularly in the marathon. Just accept that putting it on is more effort than it should be.
Product link
View more details for Salomon S/Lab Phantasm 3
This product is mentioned in the review. Check the specifications, options, and compatibility before buying.
View more details for Salomon S/Lab Phantasm 3