Running Shoes
Nike Zoom Fly 5 vs the Rest: How It Stacks Up Against 4 Popular Running Shoes
A practical comparison of the Nike Zoom Fly 5 against the Invincible Run Flyknit 2, Adizero Boston 10, Endorphin Speed 3, and Magic Speed.
Introduction
The Nike Zoom Fly 5 has generated plenty of requests for comparisons against other current models, and for good reason. It sits in an interesting spot: plated, cushioned, and versatile, but heavier than the originals that made the line famous. In this roundup we look at how it stacks up against four very different shoes: the Nike Invincible Run Flyknit 2, the Adidas Adizero Boston 10, the Saucony Endorphin Speed 3, and the Asics Magic Speed.
Nike Zoom Fly 5 vs Nike Invincible Run Flyknit 2
This is one of the most interesting comparisons available, because Nike sells two models that can look like they fit the same use case. The Invincible Run Flyknit 2 is only marginally heavier, roughly six grams more than the Zoom Fly 5, and much of that extra weight lives in the upper, which carries more padding and feels far more present on foot. The Invincible uses full Zoom X foam, while the Zoom Fly 5 only has scraps of it in the midsole.
{{image:1}}
On the road, the two feel very different. The Invincible’s squashy, forgiving ride suits very long distances or easy recovery days when you want to ease the load on tired legs. The Zoom Fly 5’s upper feels like a feather in comparison, and its midsole is more rigid and responsive, feeling better at pace. The Invincible can soak up energy like a sponge, while the Zoom Fly 5 feels like it propels you forward, with that familiar toe-off feel from earlier Zoom Fly models still intact. The Invincible’s upper has improved over the first version and proved breathable and flexible on initial runs, though it still lacks the supple feel you might want from a plush recovery shoe. If you had to pick one right now, the Invincible edges ahead purely because there is nothing quite like it, but both could fit into the same rotation.
View more details for Nike Invincible Run Flyknit 2
Nike Zoom Fly 5 vs Adidas Adizero Boston 10
The plate is more noticeable in the Zoom Fly 5 than any of the technology built into the Boston 10. The Boston is denser, a touch heavier, and needed a longer break-in out of the box, taking roughly 30 to 40 miles before softening into a more enjoyable ride. On first appearance the two are close in terms of tech, with dual foam midsoles in both, and both were once highly regarded training and racing options.
{{image:2}}
Neither shoe really fits that racing role anymore. The Boston 10 is a clear 70 grams heavier than its predecessor, and the Zoom Fly 5 is a good 60 grams heavier than the original. Since most running is training rather than racing, that may not matter much, but scaling of materials can be an issue in larger sizes; smaller sizes may suit the Boston better, while anything above size 11 can feel hefty in the Zoom Fly 5. The Zoom Fly 5’s upper is on point here, while the Boston 10 can feel a bit like a straight jacket across the top of the foot. In this pairing, the Zoom Fly 5 is the pick.
View more details for Adidas Adizero Boston 10
Nike Zoom Fly 5 vs Saucony Endorphin Speed 3
It is hard to make a case for the Zoom Fly 5 against the Endorphin Speed 3. There are similarities: both have a plate, and pricing is reasonably close. But the Speed 3 is soft, responsive, and simple, and it easily beats the Zoom Fly 5. The stability improvements and higher weight have nerfed the Zoom Fly 5 a little, making it feel slightly like a harder cell, while the Speed 3 stays lighter and nimble, with a devoted following since the first iteration.
{{image:3}}
That loyalty is backed by numbers: when runners were polled on the best marathon shoe, the Endorphin Speed came out on top with thousands of votes, and several fans own multiple pairs. Saucony has resisted changing the formula, and it keeps working. That said, the more rigid Zoom Fly 5 will have its fans, and its carbon plate, versus the nylon plate in the Speed, may provide enhanced durability and longevity over time. The Speed 3 did lose a little magic over the first 100 miles for some, while the Zoom Fly 5 is unlikely to do that and may suit higher-paced work better despite its weight. If you had to choose one, it would be the Endorphin Speed 3.
View more details for Saucony Endorphin Speed 3
Nike Zoom Fly 5 vs Asics Magic Speed
The Magic Speed is a very aggressive offering from Asics, and with the Zoom Fly 5 now leaning more versatile and mass market, the comparison is closer than you might expect. The Magic Speed is a low-stack shoe compared to the Zoom Fly, with a super thin upper and vastly lower weight, roughly 70 grams less. Both shoes are serviceable in terms of outsole grip.
{{image:4}}
Because the Magic Speed has been discounted heavily by many retailers, it presents better value than the Zoom Fly 5 if all-out pace is the goal. But it is not a daily trainer: it is hard to imagine a runner using the Magic Speed every day, in the same way a niche race shoe rarely becomes a frequent-use option. The Zoom Fly 5 is the better fit for varied daily running, while the Magic Speed earns its place for pace days.
View more details for Asics Magic Speed
Overall Buying Advice
If you want one shoe for longer, faster-paced runs, the Zoom Fly 5 fits the bill, but do not expect full Zoom X super shoe performance from it; if that is what you are after, a more expensive, slightly lighter option like the Tempo Next% is a better fit. For recovery and easy days, the Invincible Run Flyknit 2 is the one to grab. The Endorphin Speed 3 remains the safest all-round pick, while the Magic Speed and Boston 10 serve more specific niches.
Conclusion
The Zoom Fly 5 is a versatile plated trainer with a superb upper and a familiar toe-off feel, but each rival here wins on its own terms: the Invincible for plush recovery, the Boston 10 for smaller sizes, the Endorphin Speed 3 for soft responsiveness and marathon pedigree, and the Magic Speed for discount-priced pace. Match the shoe to the run you actually do most.