Running Shoes
Nike Vaporfly Next% 2 vs Puma Deviate Nitro Elite: Two Carbon Racing Shoes Compared
The benchmark carbon racer against Puma's more affordable Nitro Elite: stack, weight, ride feel, fit and value compared for road runners.
Introduction
Two top-tier carbon racing shoes, two very different propositions. The Nike Vaporfly Next% 2 is widely regarded as the benchmark carbon racer, a shoe with a lineage going right back to the original 4%. The Puma Deviate Nitro Elite is the outsider: less widely known, harder to get hold of in the past, but now available in the UK and coming in at a notably lower price than both the Vaporfly and Puma’s newer, limited-availability Fast-R shoe.
That availability question is why the Nitro Elite still deserves attention. Puma’s new flagship racer is being released in very limited quantities worldwide and is not broadly available in the UK for the time being, while the Nitro Elite is easier to find and sits at a friendlier price point. So how do these two actually stack up?
At a Glance: Spec Comparison
Both shoes share an 8mm drop. Nike does not officially publish stack heights, but the Vaporfly Next% 2 sits close to the 40mm limit, slightly lower than the Alphafly. The Puma Deviate Nitro Elite comes in at 36mm, though it genuinely feels lower than that number on the run.
Weight is close. The Nitro Elite weighed 201g (7.1oz) in UK size 9, while the Vaporfly Next% 2 came in at 206g (7.3oz) in the same size, so the Puma is slightly lighter. On price, the gap is more dramatic: the Nitro Elite costs around 170 pounds or 200 euros, with some colourways available at 160 pounds, while the Vaporfly Next% 2 runs 210 pounds or 225 dollars in some colours and 225 pounds or 240 dollars in most. That means the Puma can come in roughly 40 to 55 pounds cheaper depending on the colourway you find.
{{image:1}}
Design and Uppers
The Vaporfly Next% 2 moves away from the crisper, packet-like Vaporweave of the original Next% to a softer knitted upper. It is raised slightly more at the front, has a touch more padding on the tongue, but remains a very minimal, very lightweight racing upper with little cushioning around the heel.
The Puma uses a mono mesh upper: not as open as the Nike knit but still breathing well and extremely lightweight. There is minimal padding at the heel and nothing at all on the tongue. Both uppers are clearly engineered with weight saving as the top priority, and both succeed.
{{image:2}}
Midsoles and Outsoles
Nike pairs its full ZoomX midsole with a full-length carbon plate, with a slight scoop shape at the front of the outsole. ZoomX needs little introduction: very light, very bouncy and very impressive. The outsole gets a good rubber covering on the forefoot and two strips at the rear, leaving a small amount of exposed foam at the heel. As a heel striker you may chew a little of that exposed foam, but durability has not been a major concern on road and track use.
Puma uses a nitrogen-infused PWRPLATE-era foam that is different from the rest of its Nitro range: lighter, softer and bouncier, reserved for its top racing shoes. The carbon plate here is a full-length inner plate that forks at the front. The outsole is Puma Grip LT, a lightweight stripped-back version of the excellent Puma Grip compound used across the Nitro range. It still grips well, including on sharp turns in wet conditions, and covers both heel and forefoot. There is a little exposed foam, so this is a road shoe, not a trail option.
Fit and Comfort
Both shoes were true to size, with a comfortable amount of room in the toe box for long runs while still locking down securely. The concerns on both shoes sit at the heel. The Vaporfly Next% 2 caused some heel rubbing early on with its new heel design, solved by heel-lock lacing and careful lacing, with no significant problems since.
The Nitro Elite was actually one of the better Puma shoes for heel comfort: the standard Deviate Nitro caused heel rub above the hour mark, but the Elite version’s slightly tighter, more locked-down fit kept problems to a minimum.
Ride and Performance: Nike Vaporfly Next% 2
This is the proven commodity. The Vaporfly Next% 2 is genuinely fast, light and punchy, and there is really no race distance it is not good for: 5K, half marathon, marathon, or short sharp intervals. It is comfortable enough that, if you do not have stability issues, it can even handle a fair bit of training, though most people will want to keep it for race day given it is not the most durable shoe and can feel a bit unstable at easy paces.
For longer events, some runners may prefer the Alphafly within Nike’s own range, but the Vaporfly remains a fantastic racing shoe at any distance and there is very little to fault.
Ride and Performance: Puma Deviate Nitro Elite
The Nitro Elite is the more natural ride of the two. It has a fairly lower, firmer feel with no exaggerated bounce or squish and no aggressive rocker, yet it still delivers what you want from a super shoe: more efficiency and leg protection from soft, light foams. It feels closer to the original Vaporfly 4% than to the maxed-out modern stack.
That lower, more grounded character makes it excellent for tighter corners; in a 5K race it handled aggressive cornering in the park confidently, thanks in part to the strong Puma Grip outsole. It also protects the legs more than the ride suggests. During an intense marathon training block it handled a hard 27km session, a sub-16 5K race and 10 x 1km reps at 3:15 pace on the track, along with a half marathon at around 1:15 pace, all while keeping legs feeling protected under heavy mileage.
It is firmer than the Vaporfly, so the most cautious marathon runners may hesitate, but for lighter runners and anyone racing 5K to half marathon it is a great option, and it would not be an unhappy compromise for a marathon.
{{image:3}}
Durability and Verdict
On paper the easy verdict is the Vaporfly Next% 2: the proven shoe most runners love and the safe pick for any race distance if money is no object. But in the real world, price matters, and the Nitro Elite undercuts it by 40 to 55 pounds at RRP while performing close to it, especially at 5K, 10K and half marathon distances.
The Puma may also take more of a beating: the Puma Grip LT outsole held up impressively, showing no real dent in feel or wear after more than 100km. The Vaporfly is a little underrated on durability too, with older versions happily passing 500km, but the Puma likely has a slight edge. At 160 to 170 pounds, the Nitro Elite also costs around the price of many plated training shoes, making it a genuinely interesting option for runners who like to train in carbon shoes, or even as a training companion to a Vaporfly.
For anyone moving into super shoes now, especially fans of the newer lower-stack racing shoes, or those who prefer a more natural, grounded ride, the Nitro Elite is absolutely worth trying. If you want the benchmark and the most proven racer, the Vaporfly Next% 2 is still the one to beat.
{{image:4}}
Conclusion
The Nike Vaporfly Next% 2 remains the default answer for pure racing performance at any distance. The Puma Deviate Nitro Elite, however, offers nearly comparable performance, particularly in shorter events, a more natural and stable ride, and a significantly lower price. Runners entering the super shoe world or wanting a fast, grounded racer with better value have a genuinely strong alternative in the Puma.

