Running Shoes

New Balance Fresh Foam X Rebel v4 vs Hoka Mach 6: Two Lightweight Trainers Compared

Two featherweight daily trainers with different foams, similar ride feel, and one very close call between them.

Two lightweight running shoes side by side on a concrete studio floor

Introduction

Some shoe comparisons are easy because the shoes are wildly different. This one is hard for the opposite reason: the New Balance Fresh Foam X Rebel v4 and the Hoka Mach 6 are so similar in feel that it is genuinely possible to forget which one is on your foot. Both are lightweight, plateless daily trainers with simple uppers, straightforward outsoles, and a special sauce that lives almost entirely in the midsole foam.

Both work the same way in a rotation: easy miles most days, with the lightness to naturally turn up the pace when your legs feel fresh. Here is how they differ.

The Foam Inside Each Shoe

The Rebel v4 uses a PEBA-EVA blended foam in a single slab, while the Mach 6 moves to a new EVA supercritical foam, also as one piece. That last part matters: the previous Mach used a dual-density setup with an EVA base and a supercritical insert, so this generation simplifies things into one slab that works very well.

Neither shoe has a plate, so you do not get that extra pop propulsion feel found in plated trainers. What you get instead is a smooth, light, responsive ride. If you are coming from heavier daily trainers that can push toward 11 ounces, either of these will feel like floating.

Runner picking up the pace on a smooth morning road run

Stack Height and Cushioning

On paper, the specs are confusingly different: the Rebel v4 is listed at 30 mm heel to 24 mm forefoot, while the Mach 6 is listed at 37 mm to 32 mm. To the eye, though, the shoes look nearly identical in stack, with nowhere near the 7 mm of difference the spec sheet implies. Some brands measure midsole only, while others include the outsole, insole, and strobel board for true total stack, which is the more honest number for what sits under your foot.

Ignore the paper discrepancy here. Both shoes have enough cushioning to function as true daily trainers, which is a shift from older tempo shoes that sat closer to the ground and fell out of rotation because they were strictly speed-day tools. These can do everything.

Close-up of a thick cushioned running shoe midsole resting on concrete

Fit and Uppers

Both uppers are minimal and no-frills. The Rebel v4 uses New Balance’s Phantom Fit, a thin, light, minimal-padding upper with a gusseted tongue and a secure midfoot lockdown. The Mach 6 keeps things similarly simple with a basic knit upper and straightforward lacing.

The fit difference is the clearest separator between the two. The Mach 6 runs a bit more snug, while the Rebel v4 has a wider platform, more forefoot space, and a more accommodating feel overall. Narrow-footed runners may prefer the Hoka’s slimmer shape; wider feet will likely be happier in the New Balance. Notably, the Rebel v4’s wider platform closely mimics the fit of New Balance’s plated elite racing shoe, just without the plate or full PEBA midsole, making it a natural training partner for that shoe.

Overhead view of two running shoes side by side for width comparison

Weight

Weight is where the Rebel v4 pulls ahead. A women’s size 7.5 weighed 6.8 ounces, described as basically racing-flat territory, while the Mach 6 in the same size came in at 8.6 ounces. In men’s sizing around a size 10, the Rebel was about an ounce lighter as well. On foot, the difference is not dramatic because both are very light, but if weight is your tiebreaker, the New Balance has the edge.

Durability and Long-Term Feel

Both foams start out feeling fresh, and neither dies out completely, but both lose some of that out-of-the-box bounce at the toe after the first stretch of miles. One tester logged close to 100 miles in the Rebel v4 and reports it no longer feels brand new but still rides light and smooth with plenty of cushioning. The Mach 6 still felt good past 30 miles.

Durability concerns around earlier Mach models appear to have been addressed. The Mach 4 and Mach 5 skipped outsole rubber entirely and ran EVA foam as the outsole, which wore quickly. The new supercritical foam blend holds up well over time, and this generation should not give you durability problems.

Well-worn running shoes on a porch after a long training block

Which One Should You Buy?

This is a very close call, and honestly you cannot go wrong with either. If you already like Hoka and its fit, the Mach 6 is an easy choice. If you prefer New Balance’s more angular, aggressive styling, the lighter weight, and a more accommodating width, the Rebel v4 is the pick. For wider-footed runners, the Rebel v4 is the safer bet; for narrow feet, the Mach 6’s snugger fit may feel more dialed.

Conclusion

The Rebel v4 and Mach 6 prove that two shoes can share a ride personality and still split the market cleanly on fit and weight. Both are smooth, light, cushioned enough for everyday training, and fast enough to race in a pinch. Choose by fit first, brand preference second, and you will end up happy either way.

Product link

View more details for New Balance Fresh Foam X Rebel v4

This product is mentioned in the review. Check the specifications, options, and compatibility before buying.

View more details for New Balance Fresh Foam X Rebel v4

Further reading

Related Reviews

Nike Pegasus Trail 5, On Cloudsurfer Trail, and Merrell Nova 4 running shoes on concrete

Running Shoes

Best Road-to-Trail Running Shoes: Three Versatile Options for Mixed Terrain

A practical guide to three road-to-trail running shoes that handle both pavement and mild trails, with clear strengths and trade-offs for different runner types.

6/27/2026
Three running shoes displayed side by side on concrete: Asics Gel Kayano 31, Brooks Ghost 16, and ON Cloudsurfer 7

Running Shoes

Best Running Shoes for Achilles Tendonitis: Three Options Explained

Three running shoes with different heel drops and support features designed to help reduce Achilles tendon pain during walking and running.

6/29/2026
Five women's running shoes arranged in descending staircase pattern on concrete

Running Shoes

Best Running Shoes for Women: Five Top Choices Ranked

A ranked guide to five women's running shoes, from versatile daily trainers to high-performance racing options, with real strengths and trade-offs for each.

6/27/2026