Running Shoes
New Balance FuelCell SC Elite V4 vs V5: Which Flagship Racer Should You Buy?
Two very different generations of New Balance's flagship carbon plate racing shoe. Here is how the wide, stable V4 and the lighter, sharper V5 compare for training and racing.
Introduction
When brands update their flagship carbon plate racing shoe, the new version is often only a small step forward. That is not the case here. The New Balance FuelCell SC Elite V5 is a genuinely different shoe from the SC Elite V4, which makes this comparison especially useful if you are weighing up the two, or wondering whether to upgrade.
Both sit at the top of the range as the brand’s flagship carbon racers, and both share the same price, £260 in the UK and $250 in the US. The older V4 may now appear in sales since it has been replaced. On paper they look similar, but on the run they add up to two very different experiences.
Spec Comparison: Weight, Drop and Stack
The headline difference is weight. The SC Elite V5 comes in at 210 g (7.4 oz) in a UK 9 / US 9.5, while the SC Elite V4 is a noticeably heavier 243 g (8.6 oz) in the same size. That is a big gap for a racing shoe and it shapes the entire character of each version.

Both shoes share a 40 mm heel stack, so the midsole height is not the differentiator. The drop is: the V4 sits at 4 mm (40 mm heel to 36 mm forefoot) while the V5 rises to 8 mm (40 mm heel to 32 mm forefoot). The higher forefoot on the V4 and its wider platform do much of the work in making it feel like a larger, more supportive shoe.
Upper, Fit and Comfort
Both shoes use lightweight, breathable uppers with minimal padding, which is exactly what you expect from a racing shoe. The key change is at the heel: the V5 has a redesigned heel collar with a little extra padding that holds the heel more securely.

This matters because the V4 had a known issue where the collar could rub the heel or Achilles and break the skin on some runners. In testing the V5 showed no heel rub at all, even in its normal lacing configuration. On length, both shoes fit true to expectations with enough toe room, though the V4 has one of the widest toe boxes of any carbon plate shoe, while the V5 runs narrower and more traditional. Wide versions of the racing range are typically available from this brand, which is rare among carbon racers.
Midsole and Plate
Both shoes use the 100% PEBA version of FuelCell foam, the lightest and springiest variant, paired with an Energy Arc carbon plate. That is where the similarities end.
The V4’s midsole is wider, contributing to its heavier weight and more stable, springy character. The V5 is much narrower and nimbler, with a stiffer forefoot in the plate that produces a more propulsive feel off the toes. The trade-off is real: the V5 is less stable, but faster and more aggressive.
Outsole and Grip
The outsole configuration is the same on both: rubber over the forefoot and two strips at the back. The V5, however, gets a new tackier rubber compound with small shallow triangular tread shapes, aimed at improving grip over the V4.

In practice the rubber and tread pattern give the V5 a slightly more secure feel on quick turns, though both are road racers rather than trail shoes.
Ride Feel: Wide and Cruisy vs Narrow and Aggressive
Roughly 60 km was run in each shoe, covering hard training sessions, long runs, marathon pace efforts and short sharp intervals. They feel very different.
The V4 is the cruisier of the two. It is stable, comfortable and wide, with the width genuinely supporting the sides of each foot. It feels great at marathon pace, but the weight works against it when pushing to faster paces, and it never feels especially direct. For a high-cadence runner who prefers a nimbler racer, it can feel more comfortable than fast.
The V5 is the opposite. It has a more noticeable forefoot rocker, a poppy and punchy feel off the plate, and it throws you forward onto the forefoot, aided by the higher drop. It feels like a faster all-round racing shoe, and clearly better over shorter distances such as 5K races or track sessions, while the PEBA foam still leaves enough comfort for a marathon.
Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
These two shoes suit different runners, so the right pick depends on what you want.
Choose the SC Elite V4 if you want a stable, wide, accommodating and cushy carbon plate shoe. It is one of the better options in that category right now, since few brands make racers like this anymore, and it may well be discounted now that the V5 has launched. It is a very approachable first carbon racer and a good choice for heavier runners who want a bouncy, supportive ride. Over a marathon, its extra comfort may matter more than the V5’s speed advantage.

Choose the SC Elite V5 if you found the V4 too big, heavy and cushy. It is lighter, more aggressive and generally the faster shoe, especially at shorter distances, and it fixes the heel rubbing problem. The downsides are lower stability and a less accommodating fit. One honest caveat: if you love the V4, do not automatically upgrade, because the feel is quite different. And if you are shopping purely for a sleek, lightweight, propulsive racer, some rival brands offer alternatives of that type that are arguably stronger. The V4, in contrast, stands out in its own stable-and-cushy niche.
Conclusion
The FuelCell SC Elite V4 and V5 are not two versions of the same shoe so much as two different racers sharing a name. The V4 is wide, stable, comfortable and forgiving; the V5 is lighter, narrower, stiffer and faster. Buy the one that matches your running style rather than assuming newer is better, and if the V4 suits you, look for it on sale.

