Running Shoes
Hoka Mach X Review: A Max-Cushion Trainer That Trades Excitement for Stability
The Hoka Mach X adds PEBA foam and a PEBAX plate on top of a tall 39mm stack, but the question is whether it's truly better than the Mach 5.
Introduction
The Mach 5 was one of the standout daily trainers of 2022, so expectations were high when Hoka introduced the Mach X as its more ambitious sibling. The Mach X brings a PEBA racing-caliber foam, a PEBAX plate, and a max-cushion stack height to the Mach family. The obvious question is whether newer and bigger actually means better.
Hoka supplied the pair for evaluation with no editorial oversight, so the impressions below reflect genuine testing across a range of paces, from easy runs all the way up to 10K effort.
Specs at a Glance
The Mach X is a tall shoe. It comes in at 39 mm of stack height in the heel with a 5 mm drop, giving 34 mm in the forefoot. Weight is a respectable 9.4 oz (266 g) for men at a size 10, with a US men’s size 9 sample coming in slightly lighter at 9.2 oz (260 g).
Construction and Materials
There are three key components in the midsole. The top layer is a lighter-colored PEBA foam, which is some of the best material you can put in a running shoe right now. Underneath sits a layer of EVA, the more standard midsole material. Between the two is a PEBAX plate, formulated with plate-like properties, visible through a small cutout window on the bottom of the shoe.
{{image:2}}
The EVA layer is protected by Hoka’s Durabrasion Rubber, with good forefoot coverage, flex cutouts to help the shoe bend, and some exposed foam toward the rear. The heel uses a swallowtail design reminiscent of the standard Mach, but made considerably more aggressive, splitting the left and right parts of the heel.
The upper is a jacquard mesh that keeps things breathable while still offering decent durability. The tongue is very thin but includes a large pad where the laces crisscross over the forefoot to protect against lace pressure, and it is gusseted on both sides. The heel cup has structure at the bottom that flares into an Achilles flare, ending in a slight pinch familiar from other Hoka shoes.
Underfoot Feel and Ride
Overall, this is a really good shoe. The PEBA foam is pleasant to run in, absorbing impact well when the foot lands while still offering a nice amount of spring. The firmer EVA carrier, especially under the arch region, curls up and around the softer PEBA top layer and prevents the ankles from rolling in too far either way.
{{image:1}}
Across easy pace all the way up to 10K pace, the shoe was genuinely fun to run in. It turns over well thanks to the early stage meta rocker, and the ride feels peppy.
The main critique is that the PEBAX plate may not have been the right choice. The plate appears to do much the same job in the forefoot that the firmer EVA does in the rear: stabilizing the PEBA foam. While stability is welcome in a soft shoe, so many stabilizing elements, the firm EVA carrier plus the plate, mute some of the excitement that PEBA can bring. At moderate, marathon-effort paces, the full decompression and spring-back of the PEBA was missing, and during threshold repeats the shoe felt like it was dampening the experience slightly. At easy paces it felt great, but the Mach 5 also feels great at easy paces, and its plate-free supercritical foam arguably feels springier.
How It Compares to the Mach 5
The biggest problem the Mach X faces is that it has to be meaningfully better than the Mach 5 to justify existing, and that is where the nitpicking starts. At easy paces, the supercritical layer in the Mach 5 is preferable to the PEBA layer in the Mach X, because with no plate the foams are allowed to feel more springy, even if that costs some stability.
{{image:3}}
The other frustration is fit. These are both Mach shoes, but they fit very differently. The Mach X felt very snug, both in toe-side space and in volume across the top of the shoe, so most people will want to size up half a size. The Mach 5 erred slightly loose in shape and volume; the Mach X went in the opposite direction and now lacks space.
Elsewhere in the market, the Mach X sits closest in feel to the Puma Deviate Nitro 2, a daily trainer package with premium racing foam and a carbon plate. The Deviate Nitro 2 delivers a bit of extra pep from its carbon plate that the Mach X’s PEBAX plate does not quite match. Hoka also appears to be aiming for something like the Nike Invincible 3, a tall-stack PEBA shoe that works well from easy pace up to marathon effort, though the Mach X’s added stabilizing elements make it a different kind of ride.
Buying Advice
The Mach X retails at $180. The Mach 5 is still widely available at its $140 full retail price, and the Deviate Nitro 2 sits between them at $160. At $180, the same price as the Invincible 3, the Mach X is difficult to recommend broadly.
The clearest audience is runners who tried the Mach X’s softer rivals, or a shoe like the NovaBlast 3, and found them too squishy and unstable. If you loved the squishy excitement of the Mach 5 or NovaBlast 3, the full-price Mach X probably is not for you.
For anyone who does pick it up, it pairs naturally into a rotation with the Rocket X 2, an all-PEBAX shoe with a carbon fiber plate that shares the early stage meta rocker, and the Bondi X for long or recovery days, where the softer EVA and smoother roll complement the Mach X well.
Conclusion
The Hoka Mach X is a really good daily trainer: springy and modern without feeling squirrely underfoot, capable from long runs through speed work. Its weaknesses are the muted pep at faster paces and a snug fit that will push many buyers up half a size. If maximum squish and excitement are your priorities, the Mach 5 remains the better easy-pace pick, but if you want PEBA cushioning with more structure, the Mach X makes a lot of sense.
Product link
View more details for Hoka Mach X
This product is mentioned in the review. Check the specifications, options, and compatibility before buying.
View more details for Hoka Mach X