Art Supplies

Faber-Castell Pitt Graphite Matte Pencils: Deep Blacks Without the Sheen

A graphite pencil range built to deliver rich, matte darks that ordinary graphite simply cannot match under direct light.

Set of eight matte graphite pencils with blending stump, sharpener and eraser on concrete

Introduction

Graphite artists have long faced a frustrating limitation: the soft B-range pencils that produce the deepest darks also produce a shiny sheen that shifts to a silvery look under direct light. Faber-Castell’s answer is the Pitt Graphite Matte range, a set the company describes as a world first for reduced reflection on paper. According to the product literature, artists have been searching for a lead like this for years, promising maximum tonal value density, incredible depth effect, and deep matte blacks.

The big open question is what exactly is inside the core. Faber-Castell has confirmed the pencils are not carbon and not charcoal, and consistently describes them simply as a graphite pencil with a matte finish. The exact formulation is not disclosed, which is normal for pencil manufacturers protecting their formulas. If you want the deep darks of graphite without mixing in other mediums, that distinction matters more than the recipe.

Who This Product Is For

These pencils are aimed squarely at graphite artists who want rich, deep blacks while staying within pure graphite. If you work with a graphite scale, HB sits in the centre, the H range runs harder and lighter, and the B range runs softer and darker. The problem has always been at the top of the B range: layering pencils like a 5B or 8B to build deep darks produces that silvery sheen under light.

There are alternatives, and they are worth knowing about. Staedtler’s Mars Lumograph Black is sold as a carbon-based pencil with a matte appearance, and Conté offers carbon and charcoal pencils that also produce very dark matte marks. But those are different mediums that behave differently on different papers. If you want to complete an entire piece in graphite alone without bringing in carbon or charcoal, the Pitt Graphite Matte is the clear purpose-built option.

What the Pitt Graphite Matte Range Includes

The set contains eight pencils spanning HB, 2B, 4B, 6B, 8B, 10B, 12B, and 14B, plus a paper blending stump, a small metal sharpener, and a PVC-free eraser.

Graphite pencil tonal scale swatches on smooth drawing paper under bright light

The eight degrees of hardness cover everything from mid-tones to the deepest 14B. The literature also notes the Pitt Graphite Matte is extra break resistant, lightfast, and features an environmentally friendly water-based varnish on the barrel. Sharpening caused no problems at all, whether with a handheld sharpener or a hand crank sharpener.

One practical tip for any graphite work: consider adding a putty eraser to your kit. Rubbing with a standard eraser can damage the tooth of the paper, while a putty eraser lifts graphite gently, can be moulded into a point for detailed marks, and is far more versatile overall.

Performance: How Matte Is It Really

On Bristol smooth paper, the difference becomes obvious the moment light hits the page. A regular 8B graphite pencil laid down heavily and blended shows a clear silvery appearance when tilted under bright light. The Pitt Graphite Matte 6B, laid down the same way, shows only a trace of sheen, and nothing close to what ordinary graphite produces.

Sheen visible on layered graphite strokes as paper is tilted toward light

The 14B delivers a gorgeous rich black that simply is not achievable with standard graphite at that tonal depth. In side-by-side tonal tests, the Pitt 6B came out significantly darker than a 9000 range 5B, and the 14B sat at the very top of the darkness scale within the graphite category.

There is one caveat worth learning before you start: pressing hard on matte graphite with a blending stump can reintroduce some sheen. In testing, the unblended lower portion of a 14B swatch stayed matte while the area pushed down hard with the stump developed a slight shine. Light pressure when blending preserves the matte effect.

How They Blend

Ordinary graphite moves effortlessly under a blending stump, pulling out into smooth gradients and even coverage. The Pitt Graphite Matte is slightly harder to move around, but only a little, and it still blends well enough to smooth strokes into even tonal areas.

Hand blending dark graphite strokes with a paper blending stump

The trade-off is the point of the product: what you lose in slipperiness you gain in a finish that stays matte. For artwork combining the Faber-Castell 9000 range with the Pitt Matte pencils, the deepest darks rendered with the 14B kept a matte appearance even after blending, while mid-tone areas done with regular graphite showed visible sheen under the same light. Used together, the two ranges complement each other well.

How They Compare to Carbon and Charcoal Alternatives

Staedtler’s Mars Lumograph Black pencils are carbon-based and genuinely darker in the upper grades. In direct comparison, a 6B Mars Lumograph Black came out darker than a 6B Pitt Matte, and an 8B Mars Lumograph Black appeared darker than even the 14B Pitt Matte. The carbon pencils also have a drier, less smooth feel on paper and are even harder to move with a blending stump, and they develop sheen of their own when pressed hard into the paper.

Conté’s carbon and charcoal pencils, including the Pierre Noire, add further options, but each behaves differently and some are noticeably scratchy on paper. The core distinction stands: these are different mediums with different handling, layering, and paper behaviour. The Pitt Graphite Matte’s advantage is that it keeps everything within graphite, which is why Faber-Castell can call it a world first.

Things to Consider Before Buying

The darkness ceiling matters. If your priority is the absolute darkest possible mark, carbon-based alternatives like the Mars Lumograph Black reach deeper blacks at equivalent or even lower grades. If your priority is staying in pure graphite with minimal reflection, the Pitt Matte wins.

The formula remains undisclosed. Faber-Castell states these are not carbon and not charcoal, and the world-first claim implies a treated or modified graphite core, but you will have to draw your own conclusions about the contents. Blending pressure also needs a lighter touch than you may be used to if you want to preserve the matte finish.

Buying Advice

If you are producing a complete piece and want to stick with graphite alone, the Pitt Graphite Matte range is the way to go. It delivers the rich black tonal values that graphite artists have not been able to achieve before, with reflection reduced dramatically compared to standard B-range pencils.

Detailed graphite portrait drawing in progress on a drawing board

Pairing the set with a regular graphite range like the Faber-Castell 9000 works well in practice, using the 9000 pencils for mid-tones and the matte pencils for the deepest darks. Add a putty eraser and you have a well-rounded graphite setup. For artists who do not mind switching mediums, carbon-based pencils remain worth a look for their extra darkness, but they bring different handling characteristics with them.

Conclusion

The Faber-Castell Pitt Graphite Matte pencils do exactly what they promise: deep, rich, matte darks from a graphite core, in eight useful grades from HB to 14B, with good break resistance and clean sharpening. They will not out-dark carbon-based competitors at the top of the scale, but no other pure graphite pencil comes close to their matte finish. For graphite artists who have spent years accepting the sheen as the price of deep blacks, this range is a genuine step forward.

Product link

View more details for Faber-Castell Pitt Graphite Matte

This product is mentioned in the review. Check the specifications, options, and compatibility before buying.

View more details for Faber-Castell Pitt Graphite Matte

Further reading

Related Reviews

Storage tube of watercolor pencils beside a fan of assorted colored pencils

Art Supplies

Art Pop Watercolor Pencils 48-Color Set: A Thoughtfully Designed Student-Grade Option

The Art Pop 48-color watercolor pencil set blends well, dissolves smoothly, and includes artist-friendly details like barrel-printed color names, all at an affordable price.

9/30/2026
Set of slim acrylic paint markers with colored caps beside vivid swatch strokes

Art Supplies

Artics Acrylic Markers 3mm Review: Versatile Paint Markers With a Few Caveats

A 48-color set of water-based acrylic paint markers that blend while wet, dry permanent, and keep the price low, though safety transparency remains a question.

9/30/2026
Art supplies arranged on a wooden desk including pencils, a pen, paints, and a brush

Art Supplies

Best Art Supplies Worth Your Money: Pencils, Pens, Paints, and Paper That Earned Their Spot

After years of daily use and testing, these are the pencils, pens, watercolors, gouache, brushes, sketchbooks, and erasers that stand above the rest.

9/30/2026