Performance Cars

Car of the Year Contenders 2022: Eight Driver-Focused Cars Ranked by the Way They Drive

From the Ferrari 296 GTB to the affordable Toyota GR86, eight performance cars were driven hard on gnarly Scottish roads to find the most thrilling of the year.

Lineup of eight performance cars on wet tarmac with misty Scottish hills

Introduction

People keep saying the sports car and supercar are dying, but 2022 makes a strong case otherwise. It was one of the best years in recent memory for driver-focused machines, so a field of eight contenders gathered in the UK, on gnarly and challenging roads with mixed weather, for one purpose: finding the most thrilling car of the year. Hybrids, screamers, and one genuinely affordable coupe all went head to head.

The lineup covered hybrids like the Ferrari 296 GTB and McLaren Artura, characterful mid-engine machines like the Maserati MC20, the BMW M4 CSL and Porsche Cayman GT4 RS, the V10-powered Audi R8 rear-wheel-drive Performance, the Mercedes-AMG SL55, and Toyota’s accessible GR86. Judging criteria were simple and consistent: accuracy, adjustability, feedback, and pure driving thrills. Here is how each contender fared.

Ferrari 296 GTB: The 819 Horsepower Shock

The 296 GTB arrived as an all-new car for one judge, and it blew him away within two miles. The damping is exceptional, firm but with a genuine compliance that soaks up jagged surfaces between England and Scotland. The brakes were described as brilliant, and the car feels compact rather than big, unwieldy, heavy, or scary. It channels the character of older Ferraris with the noises it creates, and it is ridiculously quick, with the full output available only in the most aggressive mode.

Red hybrid supercar driving along a winding Scottish road with misty hills

Criticism is modest: some wished the engine note were a bit louder. The styling divided opinion, but dynamically it is a shockingly good thing and a sign that the hybrid supercar future can be bright if done right. It ultimately tied for a podium position on points.

McLaren Artura: Composed, Precise, Lacking a Little Spark

The Artura is the lightest of the mid-engine supercars here, and its dynamic talents are obvious. The suspension is beautifully tuned, calm and fluid over roads that leave other cars bouncing. Steering is heavier than before and belies the hybrid system’s added weight, yet it is full of feedback, and the new damping setup makes the car predictable and beautifully adjustable. Crucially, McLaren refused regenerative braking in favor of a brake pedal with real feel, and that decision pays off on every drive.

With roughly 800 horsepower, it feels effortless over the ground while still conveying excitement. The chassis has no weak areas. What holds it back is intangible: character. The new wide-angle V6 revs and makes strong power, but it feels like a power unit rather than a firecracker. The judges loved and respected what it does, but the want factor was not quite there. It tied the Ferrari 296 GTB perfectly on points.

Maserati MC20: The Unhinged Winner

The MC20 is understated yet angry, bursting with character, and deeply compelling. Maserati took scattered pieces of magic from a chaotic past and molded them into one unforgettable supercar. It drives as well as, and in some respects better than, the Ferrari, and the noise is the whole car: a modern turbocharged engine that sounds utterly unhinged, like a group C racing machine. The judges called it a lunatic in the best possible way and, ultimately, an F40 in a world of mundane cars.

Wedge-shaped Italian supercar parked on smooth tarmac under soft light

Everything about the controls has consistency of weighting and feel. The gearbox shifts beautifully, the brakes have lovely feel, and the steering is loved for its weighting and accuracy. The main criticism is the brake pedal, which has a lot of travel and needs real pressure even once it firms up. There is not much else you would change. It looks gorgeous, it is a lovely place to sit, and in sanitized times, being a Maserati turns out to be a very appealing thing. Car of the Year.

BMW M4 CSL: Mighty Performance, Never Quite Cohesive

The M4 CSL has phenomenal brakes and mighty performance. From around four and a half to five thousand rpm upward it is quantifiably faster than an M4 Competition, and the engine is fabulous when you are in the mood for it. But the moment of clarity never arrived for any of the judges on these roads. The suspension never settles into a comfortable rhythm, the gearbox is bettered by many others here, including the GR86’s manual, and dynamically and visually it simply lacks a bit of decorum.

It dropped out of contention early, though one point in its favor stings: people kept climbing out with a very large grin, and it is roughly one hundred thousand pounds cheaper than the cheapest car here that outran it in charm. Talent is not the issue; cohesion is.

Porsche Cayman GT4 RS: Magic on the Right Road, Tragic on the Wrong One

On paper, the GT4 RS should walk a test like this. Porsche prices the same things the judges do: accuracy, adjustability, and feedback, and the Motorsport pool behind it makes it irresistible. The engine is fabulous, the gearbox is fabulous, and on the right road it delivers delicious moments of clarity where everything makes sense and you think it does not get better on four wheels.

Driver heel-toe downshifting a manual gearbox in a small sports coupe

The problem is the other roads. The ride is so stiff and uncompromising that the car bounces around, goes briefly airborne at modest speeds, and the steering wants to wrench itself out of your hands. Older RS models made every road the right road; this one does not, and with no damper adjustment to soften the blow on broken surfaces, it fell away as a contender. Brilliant when the surface cooperates, exhausting when it does not.

Audi R8: Polished, Trustworthy, a Nine Out of Ten Every Time

For the same money as the hotted-up M4, you get a largely hand-finished mid-engine supercar with an aluminum and carbon chassis and a glorious V10. People often do not get the R8, but this engine and gearbox are so good, and there is a poise to the car, a layer of polish in everything it does. It may not deliver a perfect ten, hair-on-fire drive, but every single drive is like a nine, and it retains that sense of absolute control and polish whatever you are asking of it.

Performance car positioned on a weighbridge with mountains behind

It is trustworthy, it keeps its composure even when you are getting stuck into it, and the naturally aspirated engine is pure joy once you work for it a little. Steering feel is the one area where it does not compete with the best cars here, and that sharpness deficit kept it from challenging for the win. Still deeply loved, especially by the judges who value depth over drama.

Mercedes-AMG SL55: Confused and Caught in No Man’s Land

In theory, the SL55 should be an SL for enthusiastic drivers. It is built by AMG, it is powered by the four-liter twin-turbo V8 that everyone loves, and its four-wheel-drive system is very fluid. In practice, the verdict was blunt: the car is confused, not quite a real SL and not quite an AMG GT. It feels heavy and overly complex, caught in no man’s land, and one judge did not hide his dislike at all.

Amusingly, it was the only car weighed that came in lighter than advertised. A lovely engine and a decent chassis are not enough to rescue a car that cannot decide what it wants to be.

Toyota GR86: The People’s Champion

Then there is the underdog, costing roughly a tenth of the supercars, with a mere 231 horsepower and about one hundred thousand pounds of gap to the next most expensive car. And every single judge put it in the top half of their order. This is a huge step on from the GT86: the bigger flat-four engine has more torque and far more appetite for revs, the gearbox is sweet and mechanical where the old one was sticky, and the ratios are shorter and closer where it counts. It actually feels quick now, and you can enjoy it without driving at ballistic speeds.

The star turn is the damping, tuned with a balance so delicious that the car refuses to be dropped by anything here. It is beautifully damped, light, agile, and you can feel its lack of size and weight on the move, making it a genuine cross-country weapon that the GT86 never was. The manual gearbox makes you feel more involved, and the concept has finally been nailed. The hero of the test, and pretty much perfection.

The Weighbridge Test: Who Was Honest About Weight

To settle things objectively, every car was driven onto a local weighbridge, brimmed with fuel, so claimed weights could be checked. A few kilos over the claim is expected, and the Porsche and Audi both showed bumps that were just about explainable by options and fuel. The Mercedes was the surprise, coming in lighter than its official figure. The Toyota matched its claimed weight almost exactly and was the lightest car on test by 180 kilos, some 420 kilos lighter than the Maserati.

Performance car positioned on a weighbridge with mountains behind

Verdict: How the Order Shook Out

The final standings rewarded cars that deliver thrills on real, imperfect roads. The Maserati MC20 took the overall win on character, noise, and driver reward. The Ferrari 296 GTB and McLaren Artura tied perfectly on points, both fabulous supercars and encouraging proof that the hybrid future is bright if done right. The Toyota GR86 was the hero of the test: affordable, engaging, and unimprovable in the judges’ eyes.

The Cayman GT4 RS was magic on the right road but could not cope everywhere, the Audi R8 was polished but not quite sharp enough to challenge, the M4 CSL never found cohesion, and the SL55 stayed lost between identities. If you want the biggest thrills per pound, the GR86 makes the strongest case. If you want a supercar with soul, the MC20 is the one.

Conclusion

The verdicts here all come back to one idea: the best car is not the fastest or the most exotic, it is the one you want to keep driving. The MC20 earned the overall win, the GR86 won hearts at a tenth of the price, and the tied hybrids proved electrified performance can still be thrilling. Whichever tier of the market you shop in, 2022 left enthusiasts genuinely spoiled for choice.

Further reading

Related Reviews

Four generations of Audi performance cars lined up on a concrete studio floor

Performance Cars

From S2 Coupe to B7 RS4: Four Audi Legends That Built the Fast Estate

Four Audis that trace the line from the original Quattro legacy to the ultimate high-revving fast estate: the S2 Coupe, RS2, B5 RS4 and B7 RS4.

10/15/2026
Open-wheel single-seater road car photographed at a three-quarter angle on concrete

Performance Cars

BAC Mono R Review: The Most Focused Road Car Money Can Buy

An open-wheel road car from Liverpool with graphene bodywork, 342 horsepower, and a sub-600kg kerb weight. Here's what makes the Mono R so special.

10/15/2026
Seven varied performance cars lined up on a race circuit paddock at golden hour

Performance Cars

The Best All-Wheel Drive Performance Cars: Seven Cars That Prove AWD Is More Fun Than Ever

From a five-cylinder Audi hatchback to a 1,000-horsepower hybrid Lamborghini, these seven all-wheel drive performance cars show how far traction tech has come.

10/15/2026