Running Shoes
Brooks Glycerin Max vs Puma MagMax Nitro: Two Max Cushion Trainers Compared
A side-by-side look at two big-stack daily trainers, covering fit, ride character, outsole grip, and which shoe suits easy days versus slightly quicker sessions.
Introduction
Max cushion trainers are multiplying fast, and two of the most talked-about big-stack options right now are the Brooks Glycerin Max and the Puma MagMax Nitro. On paper they look remarkably similar: tall midsoles, generous rubber outsoles, and prices that sit firmly in the premium trainer bracket. In practice, though, they deliver noticeably different rides.
This comparison focuses on how each shoe actually behaves over easy miles, recovery runs, and longer steady sessions, and where each one earns its place in a rotation.
At a Glance: Specs and Prices
The Puma MagMax Nitro costs £170 or $180, weighs 298g (10.2 oz) for men in a size 8, and has an 8mm drop. The Brooks Glycerin Max costs £180 or $200, weighs 313g (11 oz) for men in a size 8, and has a 6mm drop.
Both shoes carry a thick rubber outsole over a large midsole, which points to durability and a more controlled, stable feel rather than a wild, super-light racing experience. Neither is designed to be versatile above all else; both are firmly aimed at comfortable, cushioned running.

Fit and Sizing
Both shoes fit true to size in testing. The usual size for both Brooks and Puma worked well in terms of length, with enough room in the toe box without feeling overly spacious, and a solid midfoot hold even for narrower feet.
The two uppers differ in character. The Puma uses a soft, breathable mesh with a deluxe knitted tongue and a stretchier lacing setup geared toward lockdown, while the Glycerin Max leans into plushness with a padded traditional tongue and spongy laces. Both have a similar level of padding in the heel collar, though the heel counters differ slightly: flatter on the MagMax Nitro, more focused and narrower on the Glycerin Max.
One caveat: the MagMax Nitro’s heel design caused some Achilles rubbing for one tester with a mild Achilles tendon issue, though this was considered unlikely to be a widespread problem. For most runners, going true to size in either shoe should work well, and both are relatively broad and accommodating, with the Puma being very slightly narrower toward the forefoot.
Ride Character: Comfort First, With One Shoe a Bit More Playful
The MagMax Nitro is built around Puma’s nitrogen-injected Nitro foam, described as a balanced foam offering both responsiveness and cushioning. In practice it has a bouncier, livelier feel and a more noticeable rocker that nudges the foot through heel to toe a little quicker. That gives it a slight edge for moderate-paced running within longer sessions, though it is still not a shoe for all-out speed.

The Glycerin Max uses Brooks’s DNA Tuned foam, a nitrogen-infused midsole with large cells in the heel for soft landings and smaller cells in the forefoot for a more responsive toe-off. It combines this with a GlideRoll rocker to promote smooth heel-to-toe transitions. The ride is balanced and lively, but softer-feeling and more stability-focused, thanks to a very wide base. The rocker is present but not especially noticeable; the shoe simply delivers comfort and a smooth, secure ride.
How Each Shoe Performed on the Run
Over roughly 70k in each shoe, both felt best on easy runs, recovery runs, and longer sessions at a consistent pace. The Glycerin Max is enjoyable precisely because it disappears on the foot more than its weight suggests, rolling smoothly and making even long easy runs feel pleasant rather than laborious. An interval session in it confirmed it is not built for pace: there is not enough bounce from the midsole to reward a big, heavy shoe being pushed quickly.

The MagMax Nitro took some time to come into its own, with the midsole needing a few runs to loosen up before its bounce showed. Once bedded in, it offered a bit more pop and turnover, making it the more versatile of the two for longer efforts with tempo sections. It still falls short of a true do-it-all super trainer, and dedicated marathon-training pace work would call for something faster.
On grip, both impressed. The Glycerin Max has a solid rubber outsole that handled wet roads and canal paths without issue, and the MagMax Nitro benefits from Puma’s consistently excellent grip rubber. Both protected the midsole well and inspired confidence in wet conditions.
Which One Should You Buy?
Both shoes are comfortable, stable, and durable options for easy and long runs, and the price difference is small. The choice comes down to intent. If you want a touch more versatility and the option of picking up the pace slightly within longer sessions, the MagMax Nitro has more to offer, and it costs a little less. If you want a pure easy-day shoe that prioritizes comfort, protection, stability, and a smooth, enjoyable ride, the Glycerin Max is the stronger pick, despite being slightly more expensive.

It is also worth noting that neither shoe suits every runner’s gait. A shuffly, high-cadence runner may struggle to unlock the bounce in the MagMax Nitro’s huge stack, finding it big and heavy on the foot, while the Brooks rolls through more smoothly and feels lighter despite nearly identical weight. If you respond well to bouncy foams, the Puma could feel genuinely fun. Runners with lighter frames or gentler strides may prefer the Brooks’s firmer, more controlled feel.
Conclusion
The Brooks Glycerin Max and Puma MagMax Nitro are both very good max cushion trainers that handle big mileage with comfort and grip. The MagMax Nitro is the more versatile of the pair with a bouncier ride and a lower price, while the Glycerin Max is the more stable, comfortable, and smooth-rolling option for easy days. Choose the Puma if versatility matters, and the Brooks if pure comfort is the goal.
Product link
View more details for Brooks Glycerin Max
This product is mentioned in the review. Check the specifications, options, and compatibility before buying.
View more details for Brooks Glycerin Max