Running Shoes

Five Best Running Shoes of 2024: From Max Cushion to Race Day

Six standout shoes tested over hundreds of miles, covering daily training, comfort, fun, speed work, and racing.

Six running shoes of varied styles arranged in a row on a concrete studio floor

Introduction

Picking a best-of list is never easy, and this one required going back one more time on a shoe that almost got left off. After well over 100 pairs tested across the year, five shoes earned a spot as the best of the best: the most fun, most comfortable, most protective, and most capable designs of 2024, ordered from least expensive to most expensive.

Before the List: How These Were Picked

This is not a best-value list and not a best daily trainer list. The $140 daily trainer category is packed with great options, but those shoes are designed to be great value rather than the absolute best. This list collects the shoes that stood at the top of their respective categories: pure comfort, speed training, everyday fun, and racing.

A few notes on what qualified. Every shoe here excelled at one thing. Versatility mattered less than being exceptional at a specific job, and most of the picks around or above the $200 mark proved their worth over long blocks of training, many passing 100 miles of testing.

Runner logging miles on a wet grey road in winter conditions

Honorable Mention: Hoka Mach 6 LA

At $140, the Hoka Mach 6 sits just outside the top five but earns an honorable mention for sheer value. It uses full supercritical EVA foam with a 6 mm drop (37 mm heel, 31 mm forefoot), coming in around 257 g in a size 11.5. The ride is soft, lively, and bouncy without bottoming out, with one of the best rocker geometries in the game.

It competes directly with the Adidas Nova Blast 5 and SL2 class of trainers, running slightly softer than most of them, and proved versatile enough for everything from 5:30 pace workouts to easy long-run miles. One major caveat: sizing runs a full size small for some feet. The toe box is shallow and aggressively tapered, so trying it on before buying is strongly recommended.

Best Amped-Up Daily Trainer: Puma MagMax

At $180, the Puma MagMax is the cheapest shoe on the list and the closest to a normal shoe, just with everything dialed up to the max. Think of a max-stacked take on the classic mileage-building formula: comfort, stability, protection, bounce, and versatility, all amplified. With a stack approaching 50 mm, it still manages to feel surprisingly normal on foot.

The ride needed some miles to show its true character, initially feeling like too much foam, but it improved steadily and is built to last 400 to 500 miles. It suits easy runs, long runs, recovery days, and general daily mileage, though it is not the pick for speed workouts. The high drop is worth noting: it took load completely off sore calves in a way that lower-drop shoes could not.

Runner settling into a relaxed easy pace on a quiet suburban road

Best Speed Trainer: Hoka Mach X 2

The $190 Hoka Mach X 2 completely changed the opinion on plated trainers. Unlike many shoes in the category that feel like watered-down versions of their carbon-placed siblings, this is a genuinely different shoe: a top layer of excellent PEBA race foam, a plastic plate, and a great-fitting upper, delivering lots of speed assistance without feeling too aggressive or mushy.

It topped the versatility ranking for shoes under $200, handling everything from 5:20 pace workouts to 10-minute miles with a stroller. It is one of the few speed training shoes that can be pushed at full force with total confidence, and the top choice for marathon-paced work among non-carbon-plated shoes.

Best Comfort Shoe: Brooks Glycerin Max

The Brooks Glycerin Max is the comfort pick of the year. It takes everything loved about the last generation of max cushion shoes and amplifies it: a great rocker, huge protection, zero ground feel, and a comfortable upper. It is heavy, but in this company that is expected and easily forgiven.

For easy everyday miles and recovery runs, it is hard to beat, standing alongside the best in the pure-comfort category. It also fits roomier than most, which suits runners who prefer a relaxed fit, and the grip is excellent, up there with the best in the category.

Most Fun Shoe of the Year: Hoka Skyward X

At $225, the Hoka Skyward X is impossible to categorize, which is exactly why it stands out. It stacks a carbon fiber plate between two of Hoka’s best foams: the race foam from the Mach X 2 on top and the supercritical EVA from the Mach 6 below. The result is a shoe that pushes you along and makes every run genuinely fun.

It is not the most comfortable max-cushion shoe and not the one-shoe-for-everything pick, but it earned a place as one of the highest-mileage shoes of the year with no bad runs in it. Best suited to quicker everyday miles rather than true recovery days, it shines most around 6:40 to 7:15 pace. Lighter runners may find it firmer than expected.

Smiling runner cruising at a brisk everyday pace on open pavement

Race Shoe of the Year: Nike Alphafly 3

Depending on colorway, the Nike Alphafly 3 runs $285 to $320, and it is the best race shoe of the year. It became the highest-mileage race shoe in the rotation, handling 25-mile days and long runs with 10 miles at marathon pace without issue. The ride is aggressive, firm, and initially even felt mechanical, but it grew more valuable as fitness built through the year.

It never bottoms out under power and feels robust and substantial, making it the most reliable partner for hard speed sessions. If the goal is getting the most out of yourself on race day or in key workouts, this is the shoe. Those who prefer something less distracting for racing have alternatives, but for outright speed this is the benchmark.

Runner leaning into a hard tempo effort on an open stretch of road

Buying Advice

Match the shoe to the job: the MagMax for cushioned daily miles, the Mach X 2 for speed training, the Glycerin Max for comfort, the Skyward X for fun, and the Alphafly 3 for racing. Great $140 options like the Mach 6 prove you do not always need to spend $200, but for the best of the best, the premium picks here consistently delivered across long testing blocks.

Conclusion

Five shoes, five distinct jobs, and one honorable mention that nearly made the cut. Whether you chase cushion, speed, or fun, there is a standout here worth a close look.

Further reading

Related Reviews

Nike Pegasus Trail 5, On Cloudsurfer Trail, and Merrell Nova 4 running shoes on concrete

Running Shoes

Best Road-to-Trail Running Shoes: Three Versatile Options for Mixed Terrain

A practical guide to three road-to-trail running shoes that handle both pavement and mild trails, with clear strengths and trade-offs for different runner types.

6/27/2026
Three running shoes displayed side by side on concrete: Asics Gel Kayano 31, Brooks Ghost 16, and ON Cloudsurfer 7

Running Shoes

Best Running Shoes for Achilles Tendonitis: Three Options Explained

Three running shoes with different heel drops and support features designed to help reduce Achilles tendon pain during walking and running.

6/29/2026
Five women's running shoes arranged in descending staircase pattern on concrete

Running Shoes

Best Running Shoes for Women: Five Top Choices Ranked

A ranked guide to five women's running shoes, from versatile daily trainers to high-performance racing options, with real strengths and trade-offs for each.

6/27/2026