Running Shoes

The Running Shoe Rotations Our Testers Keep Coming Back To

Fifteen trusted trainers and racers covering easy miles, marathon build-ups, half marathon blocks and everything in between.

Lineup of modern running shoes on a concrete studio floor

Introduction

Testing dozens of shoes a year means the ones that earn a permanent place in a personal rotation have to be genuinely special. These are the shoes our testers reach for when nobody is making them run in anything: trusted picks for easy days, hard sessions, long runs and race day.

This roundup gathers the current rotations of four testers, each with different goals, preferences and training styles. One is coasting through easy miles before a marathon they are not overly fussed about. One lives in marathon training blocks and wants lightweight, responsive shoes. One is deep in a London Marathon build-up at around 80 kilos. And one is finishing a half marathon block. Their picks overlap in places, which is usually a strong signal.

Rotation One: Comfort First, Marathon Optional

This tester is not training hard right now. There is a marathon on the calendar, but the focus is easy distance rather than big interval sessions, so the rotation leans comfortable and versatile.

The easy day pick is the Brooks Glycerin Max, a shoe that gets picked up almost automatically. It is genuinely comfortable across long, relaxed runs of 10 to 15k, and while it is not built for speed training, it still lets you pick up the pace when you feel good, turning a 5:20 per kilometre cruise into a 4:50 effort without complaint. A nicely versatile cushioned shoe for exactly this kind of training.

Runner tying laces on a cushioned daily trainer at dawn on quiet streets

The easiest pick of the whole rotation was the Adidas Adizero Evo SL. It simply does a lot: comfortable enough for easy runs, nimble enough for faster sessions, with a midsole that returns a noticeable bounce. Easy runs that would normally sit at 5:00 to 5:20 per kilometre drift down to 4:45s in this shoe, yet it still feels pleasant at a truly relaxed pace. A rare do-everything trainer.

For race day, with weekly parkrun as the only real all-out speed work, the pick is the Brooks Hyperion Elite 4 PB. It feels very light on the foot with a springy, plate-assisted pop that suits 5k perfectly, and it is genuinely enjoyable up to 10k. It was tried over a half marathon distance and found lacking in softness and cushioning for that length, but for shorter races it is impressive, and it stands out as a Brooks race shoe that really delivers.

Rotation Two: Built Around Marathon Training

This tester is nearly always in a marathon block and picks shoes to match: plenty of easy-to-steady running, flat-out sessions and tempo work, with a preference for lightweight shoes, a 5 to 8mm drop and firmer, responsive foams that reward high cadence.

The race day pick was the easiest decision of all: the Asics Metaspeed Sky Paris. It has delivered marathon, half marathon and parkrun personal bests, and it remains the favourite racer on the market here. It is well under 200 grams in a normal size, with foam that protects without feeling squishy and a plate shape that gives extra lift and punch at toe-off. Some runners may find it too light and firm for a full marathon, but for this tester the featherweight build is exactly why it works: tired legs can still turn over quickly at the end of a race.

Runner training on a river path during a marathon build-up

For the easy end of training, the Hoka Mach 6 gets the nod. Some would call it a speed-focused daily trainer, but it works as a genuine all-rounder: enough cushioning for relaxed runs and long runs, light and nimble on the foot, and comfortable enough to wear walking around. The foam does not intrude on the ride, and it has even handled track reps on a trip followed by a long easy run the next day. The Asics Novablast 5 was seriously considered for this slot and is another very solid daily trainer, but the Mach 6 just feels more natural.

Rotation Two Continued: The Speed All-Rounder

The hardest pick in this rotation came down to two shoes: the Adidas Adizero Evo SL and the Hoka Mach X2. Both are versatile, fun and handle a huge range of runs. The Evo SL is a lightweight unplated shoe with a springy Lightstrike Pro midsole, while the Mach X2 is a higher-stack super trainer with a plate, two foams and a well-tuned rocker.

The Mach X2 takes the single slot. The plate gives it an edge in really fast sessions, especially over longer distances, and the higher stack and rocker setup make it ideal for marathon training long runs, including long efforts broken up with 4k repeats. It is a bit more expensive and the upper is not as comfortable as the Adidas, and there is some overlap with the Mach 6, but a plated trainer that is nearly as fast as a race shoe is a valuable thing to own.

Rotation Three: A London Marathon Build-Up

This tester is training hard for the London Marathon on a good-for-age place, holding around 50 miles a week and layering in long, painful faster efforts like holding sub-seven-minute miles for as long as possible. Preference leans light, firm and responsive with a rocker, rather than big, pillowy softness.

For the slowest, easiest miles there is a mini rotation of two. The New Balance 880 V15 was a surprise favourite: a bigger-stacked shoe that balances cushion and response without feeling slushy or clumpy, keeps some immediacy in the return, and offers good road protection and stability. It is the pick for unhurried time-on-feet runs.

Runner running fast interval reps on an athletics track

The Nike Vomero 18 has barged its way into that same slot and covers everything the 880 does, plus a bit more energy. The dual-foam setup mixing ReactX and ZoomX works beautifully: smooth, balanced between softness and response, stable at slow paces yet capable of pushing close to marathon pace. Plush comfort and an easy fit come standard, and despite a big heel stack and a slightly heavy overall build, it feels more nimble and precise than it has any right to.

For tempo work and sessions with marathon or half marathon pace intervals, the Saucony Endorphin Speed 4 remains the go-to. It feels instantly natural on the foot with that disappearing quality that marks out a great trainer, and it is balanced enough to run at almost any pace. The ProFLY PLUS foam cushions the road without sinking too far and returns a lively, punchy ride when you shift up through the gears. It has logged hundreds of miles and is still going strong, which makes it excellent value. It is almost a rotation on its own.

For the fastest all-out efforts, from 400 metre repeats to those long sub-seven-mile-farewell runs, the pick is again the Brooks Hyperion Elite 4 PB. The upper is a big part of the appeal: light, airy and snug enough for a race shoe, without that desperate need to rip it off the moment the run ends. The Pebax midsole delivers a punchy, consistent ride across stride after stride. Whether it becomes the London race shoe is still up for debate, but for hard training it is the current favourite.

Rotation Four: Half Marathon Focus

This tester is wrapping up a half marathon block, so the longest runs sit around 14 to 15 miles and much of the training is interval and repetition work targeting half marathon pace.

The daily mileage and recovery pick is the New Balance 1080 V13. It sits at a lovely weight for that kind of running, with cushioning that leans slightly softer without feeling unstable, plus just enough rocker to roll you through the stride pleasantly. The Nike Vomero 18 has also been in the mix for slightly longer daily runs with a bit more bounce, but the 1080 V13 is the shoe this tester keeps going back to.

View more details for New Balance 1080 v13

For longer runs, the choice is the Hoka Rocket X1, specifically the original rather than the 2.0. It offers a little more control and stability than the newer version while keeping many of the same qualities, in a more comfortable package. It was very reliable last year and still provides enough snap to run harder and faster over longer distances.

For uptempo work that is not quite flat-out, the Asics Superblast 2 covers everything in between. It is a well-established all-rounder, and here it has handled recovery runs, longer efforts at half marathon pace and everything else in the middle. If one shoe had to do most of this block, this would be it. It is not the tool for all-out 5k and 10k pace, but that has not been part of this training block.

For the harder, shorter interval sessions, the tester rotates through carbon-plated race shoes rather than settling on one. Two standouts worth flagging: the Saucony Endorphin Elite 2, a genuine race-day weapon that handles hard rep sessions extremely well.

And the Nike Vaporfly, another proven carbon plate racer that keeps earning a spot in the rotation for fast sessions.

Overall Buying Advice

A good rotation does not need to be complicated. Most of these testers land on the same shape: one comfortable shoe for easy and long runs, one versatile tempo or super trainer, and one race shoe for fast days. If your budget only stretches to two shoes, a capable all-rounder like the Adizero Evo SL, Mach 6 or Endorphin Speed 4 paired with a racer that suits your goal distance covers nearly everything.

Match the shoe to the training you actually do. If your weeks are dominated by easy miles, a max-cushion option like the Glycerin Max, Vomero 18 or 1080 V13 will serve you better than a second racer. If you are heavy on intervals, a plated trainer such as the Mach X2 or Endorphin Speed 4 absorbs that workload while saving your race shoes for race day.

Conclusion

Fifteen shoes, four rotations, one clear theme: the best shoe is the one that fits the running you are doing right now. Whether that is a plush daily trainer for relaxed miles, a springy all-rounder for everything in between, or a carbon-plated racer for personal best attempts, there is a trusted pick here for every kind of runner.

Further reading

Related Reviews

Nike Pegasus Trail 5, On Cloudsurfer Trail, and Merrell Nova 4 running shoes on concrete

Running Shoes

Best Road-to-Trail Running Shoes: Three Versatile Options for Mixed Terrain

A practical guide to three road-to-trail running shoes that handle both pavement and mild trails, with clear strengths and trade-offs for different runner types.

6/27/2026
Three running shoes displayed side by side on concrete: Asics Gel Kayano 31, Brooks Ghost 16, and ON Cloudsurfer 7

Running Shoes

Best Running Shoes for Achilles Tendonitis: Three Options Explained

Three running shoes with different heel drops and support features designed to help reduce Achilles tendon pain during walking and running.

6/29/2026
Five women's running shoes arranged in descending staircase pattern on concrete

Running Shoes

Best Running Shoes for Women: Five Top Choices Ranked

A ranked guide to five women's running shoes, from versatile daily trainers to high-performance racing options, with real strengths and trade-offs for each.

6/27/2026