Car Comparisons
Mercedes-AMG A45 S vs Toyota GR Yaris vs Audi RS3: Three AWD Hot Hatches Compared
Three very different takes on the all-wheel-drive hot hatch: raw simplicity, exotic five-cylinder theatre, and 400-plus horsepower technology.
Introduction
Three very different takes on the ultimate all-wheel-drive hot hatch meet on some favourite mountain roads in North Wales, plus a day at a circuit to push each car to its limits. The Mercedes-AMG A45 S is the most powerful hot hatch you can buy. The Toyota GR Yaris is now available with an automatic gearbox. The Audi RS3 has been around for a while, but it has had an update and retains its amazing five-cylinder engine. All three are four-wheel drive, all have turbochargers, and all behave slightly differently.
Toyota GR Yaris: The Honest One
The GR Yaris is the car you warm to fastest. It is small, really nicely damped, and its body control is tight enough that it works with the lumps and bumps of mountain roads. Because the car is small, you have more road to play with. On real-world roads it was not any slower than the other two, and it communicates its limits so clearly that you find your feet quickly and just get on with having fun.

Power comes from a 1.6 turbocharged three-cylinder with 276 horsepower in this Gen 2 version, a little more than the original, with a boostier character and more turbo whistling. The new eight-speed automatic is a torque converter rather than a DCT, so changes are good but slur into gear slightly rather than snapping. In return it gives the car a relentless intensity, with no pause for gear changes on a B-road.
The Yaris also wins on approachability. It has a tactility and warmth you can enjoy without driving it fast, and on many Welsh stretches it feels like it was born for direction changes. Its simplicity and honesty are its lovable core. On track, though, the confidence it gives on the road becomes its undoing: it is consistent rather than adjustable, bleeds into understeer, and feels over 100 horsepower down on the Audi and nearly 150 down on the Mercedes despite being much lighter at around 1,300 kg.
Audi RS3: The Engine and the Torque Splitter
The Audi RS3 grows on you. Initially it feels quite wide and big for a hot hatch, with some torque steer and a rear diff that can kick out and get jumpy over bumps. But once you get tuned in, its adjustable, exciting chassis and the mighty five-cylinder turbo engine make it deeply rewarding in a way older RS3s, which were wooden and understeery, simply were not.

That engine is the heart and soul of the car. It is muscular and smooth in the mid-range yet still has fire at the top end, and it produces the most pleasurable noise of the three, with a hint of Huracan and R8 in the tone. It is one of the best engines available in any car you could use as an everyday vehicle, and it gives an ordinary-looking Audi A3 a bit of exoticism.
At nearly 1,600 kg it is not a natural track car, but the torque-splitting rear differential keeps it energized and adjustable. It rotates into corners with agility like a front-wheel-drive car, then exits much more like a rear-wheel-drive car under power, so you balance the throttle rather than pinning it. It rarely feels like a conventional all-wheel-drive car, and that is exactly what makes it exciting.
Mercedes-AMG A45 S: Power Without Much Feel
The A45 S is the hardest of the three to bond with on the road. It is very effective, hugely powerful, and very quick point to point, but it feels aloof and contained. The steering has almost no on-centre feel, so you have to trust the grip is there rather than work your way into it, which makes it hard to sense how hard you are loading the car.

On paper its 2.0-litre four-cylinder turbo is the most ordinary engine here, but with 416 horsepower it feels the most energetic at high revs. It is revvy, short geared, and paired with a crisp eight-speed DCT that is sharper than the Yaris torque converter. Adaptive damping and an adjustable powertrain give a real sense of a super hatch packed with technology.
On track it is the surprise of the test. The numb zone you fight on the road disappears, the balance becomes clear, and the low, flat, pointy chassis suits the circuit. Stay committed through a corner and it gradually pivots towards oversteer in a more linear way than the Audi. It is just too heavy, overworking its tyres. Speculatively, a lighter, more aggressive version would be something genuinely special.
On Track: Where Each Car Stands
The track day separates the three. The RS3 steps up a gear with its different modes and a more playful four-wheel-drive system, and it is the car you gravitate back to because it is the most enjoyable. The A45 S reveals a different dimension of its dynamics, feeling racy and urgent, with a diff that keeps the car neutral when you get on the throttle. The Yaris is the easiest of all three to drive quickly and massively capable, but it does not come alive the way the RS3 does, and it gives almost as much as it can give on the road.

Which One Should You Buy?
Head to a great road in difficult conditions and the Yaris is still the most special at its peak, the car that best epitomizes what an all-wheel-drive car should feel like. As an all-around ownership experience, the Audi has more about it, with a spectacular engine, a genuinely adjustable chassis, and track ability the Yaris lacks, though it costs a lot more money. The A45 S suits buyers who prioritize outright power and technology over connection. Head says Yaris, heart says RS3.
Conclusion
All three are superb, but for different reasons. The GR Yaris is the honest, approachable road car that drives its heart out. The RS3 pairs one of the best engines in any everyday car with a newly exciting chassis. The A45 S is a hugely powerful, technology-rich super hatch that rewards patience. Pick the one whose character matches yours.


