Kitchen Appliances

10 Air Fryers Put to the Test: From $53 to $400, Which One Cooks Best?

Ten air fryers across every price bracket compared on heating speed, fries, cookies, bacon, chicken, noise, and cleanup.

A row of air fryers of different sizes on a concrete countertop

Introduction

Does a $50 air fryer cook as well as one that costs $400? To find out, ten air fryers were compared across heating power, french fries, cookies, bacon, and chicken, plus noise and cleanup. The results show that price alone does not decide the winner.

How They Were Compared

Each air fryer was measured the same way: how quickly it could heat a metal test piece to 200°F from a starting temperature of roughly 72°F, how fast it reached an internal ambient temperature of 200°F, power draw in watts, and noise level in decibels. Food tests covered one serving of fries at 400°F, standardized 1 oz cookies at 300°F on parchment paper, extra thick bacon at 400°F in a single layer, and chicken quarters cooked to an internal 170°F with a wireless meat thermometer.

The Contenders, Priced From Budget to Premium

Black and Decker Air Fryer Toaster Oven ($53)

The cheapest unit in the lineup is a toaster oven style air fryer that fits a 9-inch pizza or four slices of bread, with bake, broil, air fry, toast, and keep warm modes plus a removable crumb tray, bake pan, air fry tray, and wire rack. It drew around 1,210 W at its highest setting, ran a quiet 45.9 dB, but was slow, taking 9 minutes 27 seconds to heat the test piece and 44 minutes to finish chicken. Its fries came out dried out, and the bacon produced quite a bit of smoke.

Chefman 2-qt Digital Air Fryer ($60)

This compact 2-quart model has a nonstick dishwasher-safe basket, a 400°F maximum temperature, and a listed 900 W draw, measured near 960 W. It reached ambient 200°F in just 1 minute 48 seconds and the metal test piece in 7 minutes 10 seconds, both faster than the Black and Decker. Its fries were the standout: not burned, not dried out, and just about perfect in texture. Cookies were weaker, with a very doughy bottom. It is noticeably louder at 56.1 dB.

Oster 6-qt Air Fryer ($110)

The Oster is a 6-quart unit with ten preset digital functions including bake, chicken wings, dehydrate, dessert, fish, french fries, meat, reheat, whole chicken, and vegetables, plus a removable viewing window, double nonstick surface, and 60-minute timer. Measured around 1,770 W against a 1,700 W rating, it was the loudest so far at 60.5 dB. It posted the fastest metal heating time up to that point at 6 minutes 38 seconds, and its fries had near-perfect texture and taste, tying for second place overall on fries.

Cosori 9-in-1 Turbo Blaze 6-qt Air Fryer ($120)

Cosori’s 9-in-1 Turbo Blaze has a ceramic coating, a 90 to 450°F temperature range, and a claimed 3,600 RPM fan. It measured around 1,770 W and 61 dB, close to the claimed 53 dB but a bit louder. It was the most efficient overall, heating the test piece to 200°F in just 5 minutes 59 seconds, and its bacon and chicken were cooked evenly and exceptionally juicy. With a 450°F maximum that most rivals lack, it earned the best average finish in the final ranking.

Ninja 5-qt Air Fryer ($130)

The Ninja is a 5-quart, 4-in-1 machine covering air fry, roast, reheat, and dehydrate, with a claimed 75% less fat than traditional frying. It drew close to 1,800 W and was by far the loudest at 66.2 dB. Set to 400°F, its internal ambient temperature actually hit 464°F, way over target, which helped it post the fastest metal heating time of all at 5 minutes 1 second. It made the best fries of the entire test, but the aggressive airflow blew a piece of bacon on top of another, leaving two pieces undercooked, and its chicken ran slightly dry.

Philips 3000 Series Air Fryer ($140)

The Philips 3000 series offers a 6.5-quart capacity, a claimed 90% less fat, Rapid Air Plus technology for extra crispiness, and a built-in viewing window. Temperature runs from 80 to 400°F, measured around 1,740 W and 58.4 dB. It was slower than average in the heating tests at 6 minutes 48 seconds, but it was the fastest to cook chicken to 170°F at just over 16 minutes, producing juicier meat than the Ninja, and its bacon was very consistent piece to piece.

Instant Pot Air Fryer ($150)

This 6-quart Instant Pot covers six-plus functions including air fry, broil, dehydrate, crisp, roast, reheat, and bake, with a dishwasher-safe basket and a 95 to 400°F range. It measured around 1,663 W and 63.6 dB. It heated the test piece in 6 minutes 15 seconds, third fastest overall, finished fries in 8 minutes with good texture and decent crispiness, and cooked chicken in just over 20.5 minutes, juicy with a bit more crispiness than the Cuisinart.

Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven with Grill ($220)

The Cuisinart is a large toaster oven style unit that toasts six slices of bread, air fries 3 lb of chicken wings, or bakes a 12-inch pizza, with an adjustable temperature dial, 60-minute timer, and a claimed 1,800 W. It measured around 1,775 W and was relatively quiet at 50.8 dB. It was slower in the heating tests at 7 minutes 22 seconds, but its cookies were close to perfect, tying for second place, and its bacon curled noticeably less than most rivals.

T-fal 8-qt Air Fryer ($300)

The T-fal is a large 8-quart ceramic unit with a built-in wireless meat thermometer, a nontoxic ceramic claim, dishwasher-safe parts, and a 105 to 450°F temperature range. It measured around 1,727 W and sat right at 60 dB. It reached ambient 200°F in 1 minute 55 seconds, cooked chicken to 170°F in just under 20 minutes with juicy results, and its fries finished in about 10 minutes, though slightly crispy outside and a touch moist inside. Its bacon was very consistent from piece to piece.

Breville Smart Air Fryer Convection Oven ($400)

The most expensive unit is a smart air fryer that doubles as a convection oven with 13 cooking functions, super convection claimed to cut cooking time by up to 30%, an interior oven light, and a temperature range of 86 to 480°F. It can reportedly handle a 14-lb turkey and most 9 to 13-inch pans, with the longest power cord at 57 inches. It measured just over 1,800 W at 58.2 dB. Despite the premium price, it was the slowest in nearly every speed test, taking 21 minutes for fries and over 16 minutes for cookies. Its cookies and bacon, however, ranked among the best for finish quality.

French Fries Test

Each air fryer cooked one serving of fries at 400°F. The powerful basket models finished fastest: Ninja, Oster, Cosori, and Instant Pot all came in at 8 minutes, with the Ninja producing the best fries of the day. The Oster was close behind in texture and taste, while the Cosori was slightly more dried out. The Chefman did a much better job than expected for its size at 14 minutes, while the toaster oven style units struggled more: the Black and Decker took about 15 minutes with dried-out results, and the Breville was dead last at 21 minutes with a dry interior.

Standardized 1 oz cookies were baked at 300°F on parchment paper after a 5-minute preheat. Here the toaster oven style air fryers clearly outperformed the basket style ones. The Breville took the top rating with perfectly consistent tops and bottoms despite being the slowest at just over 16 minutes. The Black and Decker and Cuisinart tied for second. The Cosori and Ninja delivered a good but slightly doughy finish, while the Chefman left a very doughy bottom side.

Bacon Test

Extra thick bacon at 400°F tested evenness across four pieces. The Black and Decker, Oster, Cosori, Philips, and Breville all earned the best possible consistency rating, though the Breville’s bacon curled more than most. Speed belonged to the powerful basket models: the Ninja finished in 5.5 minutes, Instant Pot at 5.8, and Cosori at 6.5, but the Ninja’s strong airflow scrambled the strips mid-cook.

Chicken Quarters: The Longest Test

Chicken quarters were cooked to an internal 170°F after a 5-minute preheat, flipped at 12 minutes. The Philips was fastest at just over 16 minutes with juicy results, followed closely by the Ninja at 17.5 minutes, though the Ninja’s chicken ran a little dry. The Oster, Instant Pot, and T-fal all landed between 20 and 21.5 minutes with juicy, crispy chicken, and the Cosori’s came out the juiciest of all. The Breville needed close to 30 minutes and the Black and Decker a painful 44 minutes, though most units earned top ratings for the combination of crispy skin and juicy interior.

Cleanup and Noise

Cleanup effort clearly favored the basket style air fryers, with the Chefman, Oster, and Cosori rated the easiest and the Ninja close behind. The dual-purpose toaster oven style units took the most effort to clean. On noise, the Black and Decker was the quietest at 45.9 dB and the Ninja the loudest at 66.2 dB, so shoppers sensitive to sound should weigh that carefully.

Which Air Fryer Is Best?

Converting raw performance into first-to-last rankings across every graded test, the Cosori came out on top with the best average finish of 3.1, performing well in every category. The Ninja finished second at 4.4 despite running hot and loud. The Oster, Instant Pot, Philips, and Cuisinart tied for third, with the Instant Pot singled out as a good all-around pick if the Cosori is unavailable.

Two freshly baked cookies with even browning cooling on a wire rack

Conclusion

Price did not determine the winner. The $120 Cosori Turbo Blaze delivered the best overall performance, while the budget Chefman proved a compact basket fryer can outperform machines costing several times more in some tests. Toaster oven style units such as the Breville and Cuisinart shine at cookies and larger jobs, but they are slower and harder to clean. Match the style to what you cook most, and the price premium only makes sense when the capacity and features justify it.

Further reading

Related Reviews

Arboleaf smart kitchen scale on neutral countertop with digital display visible

Kitchen Appliances

Arboleaf Smart Kitchen Scale Review: Connected Cooking Made Simple

A Bluetooth-enabled kitchen scale that syncs with a nutrition-tracking app, offering real-time weight monitoring and recipe guidance for home cooks.

6/27/2026
Five air fryer and toaster oven models arranged on a neutral surface

Kitchen Appliances

Best Air Fryer Toaster Ovens Under 100: Five Practical Options for Budget-Conscious Kitchens

Five air fryer and toaster oven combinations that deliver real cooking performance without breaking the bank, each with distinct strengths for different kitchen needs.

6/27/2026
Three air fryer toaster ovens lined up on concrete surface

Kitchen Appliances

Best Air Fryer Toaster Ovens: Three Top Picks for Multi-Function Cooking

Three high-performing air fryer toaster ovens tested for versatility, ease of use, and real-world cooking results. Find the right fit for your kitchen.

6/27/2026