Best Air Fryer Toaster Ovens: Three Top Picks for Multi-Function Cooking

Why Air Fryer Toaster Ovens Matter

Air fryer toaster ovens occupy a unique space in the kitchen. They are essentially mini convection ovens that combine the functions of a standard air fryer, a toaster oven, and a full-sized oven. Unlike basket-style air fryers, these units can fit a 12-inch pizza, a whole chicken, or nine standard slices of bread, making them far more versatile for everyday cooking.

The appeal is clear: they heat up quickly, cook efficiently, and offer multiple functions in a single appliance. Many models perform up to 13 different cooking tasks and come with useful accessories like rotisserie spits. They do cost more than a standard air fryer, but the versatility often justifies the investment for households with limited counter space.

Testing Methodology

To evaluate these models fairly, we tested each unit across several key cooking tasks. We toasted bread at every available setting and recorded how long it took and how the browning progressed between levels. For air frying, we cooked one pound of frozen fries to assess crispness and texture. We baked store-bought cookie dough balls at 350 degrees for 12 minutes to evaluate baking performance. We also roasted two bone-in, skin-on chicken breasts at 425 degrees until the internal temperature reached 165 degrees, noting cooking time, skin crispness, and meat juiciness. Finally, we assessed how easy each model was to clean after use.

Best Overall: Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro

The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is our top pick, though it is the most expensive option. You are paying for quality and durability that will last for years. It features a digital interface with 13 different cooking settings and performed every task flawlessly during testing.

The unit can fit a five-quart Dutch oven, air fry with excellent results, and produce great toast. One standout function is dough proofing, which is difficult in a regular oven because the temperature cannot go low enough. The digital controls provide precision that makes a real difference in cooking outcomes. One practical note: it does not come with a drip tray, so lining the bottom rack with foil when cooking anything particularly drippy is a sensible precaution.

Best Overall Value: Cuisinart TOA-65

The Cuisinart TOA-65 is a strong alternative if you want to spend less than the Breville while still getting reliable performance. Cuisinart makes several models, but the TOA-65 stands out because it has a digital interface and excels at the core tasks: toasting, air frying, and baking. Toast and fries came out consistently well during testing.

A practical design feature is that the fry basket sits on a tray that catches crumbs and drips, which works particularly well when cooking items like chicken wings. The model has fewer accessories and extra functions than the Breville, but if your priority is solid performance at toasting, air frying, and baking, it is a smart choice.

Best Value: Cosori 12-in-1 Air Fryer Toaster Oven

The Cosori 12-in-1 Air Fryer Toaster Oven offers excellent value with 12 different cooking settings, including a ferment function that essentially turns the unit into a proof box for rising bread. What sets this model apart is the included rotisserie accessory, which opens up cooking possibilities beyond what the other two models offer.

With the rotisserie, you can cook a classic rotisserie chicken, lamb for gyros, pork tenderloin, and other meats that benefit from rotating heat. This accessory alone adds significant versatility without requiring a separate purchase. For households looking to maximize cooking functions without the premium price tag of the Breville, the Cosori delivers strong performance and practical extras.

What to Consider Before Buying

Air fryer toaster ovens are ideal if you have the counter space and want a multi-function appliance that can handle everyday cooking tasks. They essentially function as a second oven, which makes them particularly valuable in smaller kitchens where a full-sized oven is the only option.

When choosing between these three models, consider your priorities. If you want the most features and the longest lifespan, the Breville is worth the investment. If you want reliable core performance at a lower price, the Cuisinart is a solid choice. If you want the best value with unique accessories like a rotisserie, the Cosori delivers. All three models feature digital controls, which we strongly recommend because they provide the accuracy needed for consistent cooking results.

Conclusion

Air fryer toaster ovens are genuinely useful multi-function appliances that can simplify cooking and save kitchen space. Each of these three models has clear strengths and real-world value depending on your budget and cooking priorities.