Camping Stoves
MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe vs Soto WindMaster: Two Backpacking Stoves Compared
A head-to-head look at the MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe and the Soto WindMaster across boil speed, fuel use, wind performance and cold-weather cooking.
Introduction
The MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe and the Soto WindMaster are two of the most highly rated backpacking stoves available, and on paper they look almost interchangeable. Both are regulated canister stoves, both carry the same heat rating, and both fold down small enough to disappear into a cook kit.
To find out where they actually differ, the two stoves went through four side-by-side tests: boil speed and fuel efficiency with a small volume of water, performance in wind, performance with a cold fuel canister, and a large-volume boil. The results stayed close in calm conditions and became far more revealing once the conditions got harder.
How These Stoves Were Compared
Every run used the same method so the numbers would be directly comparable. Each test started with 500 ml of water measured in a graduated cylinder and poured into a 750 ml titanium pot. Water and room temperature both sat at 22°C, and the stoves were run at full blast. The water was taken up to 80°C, roughly the boiling point at 10,000 feet, which keeps the comparison relevant for high-altitude cooking.
Fuel use was measured by weight. Each stove ran from a large canister holding 658 g of fuel, deliberately filled slightly below capacity because a completely full canister carries too much pressure and skews results. The stove and canister were weighed together before and after every run, and the difference gave the fuel burned.

Three more scenarios followed. The wind test used a fan producing roughly 12.5 km/h of airflow across the burner, with the canisters brought back to room temperature first and checked with a laser thermometer. The cold test used canisters that had spent the night at -9°C in a freezer. The large-volume test moved up to 1.5 L of water in a 2 L titanium pot, run one stove at a time.
Both stoves are regulated, which means they are designed to hold output steady as canister pressure drops. That design detail matters most in the cold test, where pressure falls sharply.
MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe: Quicker in the Wind
The Pocket Rocket Deluxe was the faster stove in the small-volume test, taking 2 minutes 2 seconds to bring 500 ml to 80°C, about 13 seconds ahead of the WindMaster. It used 8.2 g of fuel to do it.
Wind was where the gap widened dramatically. With roughly 12.5 km/h of airflow hitting the burner, the Pocket Rocket Deluxe reached a boil in 5 minutes 48 seconds on 23 g of fuel. The flame was visibly pushed to one side by the airflow, but the stove kept running and kept heat under the pot.
The 1.5 L test told a similar story: 4 minutes 2 seconds and 16.5 g of fuel, nearly a minute faster than the other stove for a nearly identical amount of fuel.
Soto WindMaster: More Efficient in the Cold
The WindMaster was the more frugal stove in the small-volume test. It used 7.6 g of fuel to reach 80°C, roughly 8 percent less than the Pocket Rocket Deluxe, although it took about 13 seconds longer at 2 minutes 15 seconds.
Cold performance is where it separated itself. With the canister sitting at -9°C overnight, the WindMaster reached a boil in 2 minutes 12 seconds, only a few seconds behind the other stove, and used 8.9 g of fuel against 11.5 g. Nearly identical speed for noticeably less fuel is a meaningful result for anyone melting snow or cooking in shoulder-season temperatures.
In the 1.5 L test the WindMaster finished in 4 minutes 57 seconds using 16.1 g of fuel, so the fuel numbers stayed close even though the boil took longer.
Boil Time and Fuel Use: Head-to-Head Results
| Test | MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe | Soto WindMaster |
|---|---|---|
| 500 ml to 80°C | 2:02, 8.2 g | 2:15, 7.6 g |
| 1.5 L boil | 4:02, 16.5 g | 4:57, 16.1 g |
| Wind, roughly 12.5 km/h | 5:48, 23 g | 8:21, 26.6 g |
| Cold canister at -9°C | 2:09, 11.5 g | 2:12, 8.9 g |

Reading the table, the calm-conditions results sit within a few seconds and a fraction of a gram of each other. The larger differences appear only where conditions push the stoves: wind favours the Pocket Rocket Deluxe, and a cold canister favours the WindMaster.
Worth noting: these were single runs rather than repeated laboratory trials, so small gaps should be treated as approximate. The wind and cold results were large enough to be meaningful on their own.
Wind Performance: Where the Pocket Rocket Deluxe Pulled Ahead
The most surprising result was the wind test. Both stoves carry the same heat rating, so similar performance would be reasonable to expect, yet the Pocket Rocket Deluxe finished 2 minutes 33 seconds sooner and burned 3.6 g less fuel. The flame was pushed sideways by the airflow on both stoves, but the Pocket Rocket Deluxe clearly kept more usable heat under the pot.
That outcome runs against the assumption carried by the WindMaster’s name, and it is the single clearest performance difference found across the four tests.
Cold Weather Performance: Where the WindMaster Pulled Ahead

Canister stoves run on a propane and isobutane mix, and the two gases behave differently in the cold: propane boils at around -4°C while isobutane boils at around -12°C. Holding the canisters at -9°C kept them inside a range where the full mixture could still be used, rather than burning off propane alone.
At that temperature, the WindMaster matched the other stove’s boil time almost exactly while using noticeably less fuel, which points to a regulator that copes better with low canister pressure.
There is a limit to this, though. Neither stove performs well once temperatures drop below -12°C. At that point, an inverted canister stove or a white gas stove is the more sensible choice.
What the Differences Mean in Everyday Use
For most trips, the two stoves will feel interchangeable. Both get water hot, both hold a simmer, and the gaps in calm conditions amount to seconds and grams that few people would notice while cooking dinner.
The differences only become clear when conditions get demanding. A windy ridge or an exposed alpine campsite rewards the Pocket Rocket Deluxe. A cold-weather trip where fuel weight matters rewards the WindMaster.
Overall Buying Advice

Pick the MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe if you cook in exposed, windy places and want the stove that keeps the most heat under the pot when airflow is working against you. It was the faster stove in three of the four tests and the clear winner in wind.
Pick the Soto WindMaster if cold-weather fuel economy matters more than raw speed. It used less fuel in calm conditions, in the large-volume test, and especially with a cold canister, while giving up only seconds on boil time.
Either way, both stoves are strong choices, and the decision comes down to which conditions you actually cook in.
Conclusion
The MSR Pocket Rocket Deluxe and the Soto WindMaster are both capable backpacking stoves, and neither is a poor purchase. The Pocket Rocket Deluxe is the better performer in wind. The WindMaster is the better performer with cold fuel and the more efficient stove overall in calm conditions. Match the stove to the conditions you meet most often, and either will serve you well.

